STEM Education

  • Comment (4)

Women, Minorities Vastly Underrepresented in Engineering Profession

October 28, 2011 RSS Feed Print

The number of minority professionals in engineering is creeping up, but not fast enough, according to a new report by the National Action Council for Minorities in Engineering.

"We continue to see modest increases at every level of engineering," Irving Pressley McPhail, CEO of the organization, says. "But the larger question remains—and that is the issue of proportionality. As the underrepresented population continues to grow, the number of them becoming engineers hasn't kept pace."

Though African-Americans and Latinos make up 12 and 16 percent of the U.S. population, respectively, they make up just 5 and 6.2 percent of the engineering workforce. Women are similarly underrepresented: Just 13.4 percent of engineering professionals are women.

McPhail says the dwindling proportion of minority engineers are "threatening the U.S. pre-eminence in STEM," and that the United States needs to tap into the "hidden talent" of minorities.

[Read McPhail's opinion piece: The 'New' American Dilemma.]

The organization is compiling a list of best education practices and STEM programs to try to re-engage and initiate minority students' interest in STEM fields.

"We're really now beginning to zero in on the evidence for what works," he says. "At the beginning, there were a lot of ideas thrown at the problem. We've been at this long enough that we're seeing some models emerge, and they're worthy of more exploration and resource support."

Last week, the organization held a national symposium in St. Paul to release its findings, with experts from organizations such as ExxonMobil, the National Academy of Engineering, and PBS NewsHour. McPhail says he didn't want to waste the experts' time by rehashing old ideas—he wanted to talk about solutions.

"I did not want to bring a group of committed, passionate, and bright people to talk about the problem," he says. "I wanted to talk about what they have learned and what concrete action is beginning to show some signs of success."

The organization recommends increasing the number of paths students can take to successful engineering careers. Instead of one "pipeline" that runs through four-year universities and graduate programs, the organization recommends that students look for "the various ways that individuals might obtain the skills and training necessary to join the engineering workforce rather than using a cookie-cutter, one-size-fits-all approach."

McPhail says two-year associate's degrees are often sufficient to find viable work opportunities in the field, but that community colleges should be seen "not as a stopping point, but as a starting point." Half of the nation's community colleges have engineering transfer programs that can be used as a stepping stone for a bachelor's or master's degree in the field, he says.

He recommends that companies and states begin focusing on STEM at an earlier age and help students who have dropped out re-enter high school and community college.

"The key is to look at all of this as a continuum," he says. "You've got to start early, beginning in middle school. Actually, if we had money, we'd begin [pushing STEM] in kindergarten."

Have something to share? Send news and submissions to stem@usnews.com.

Tags:
engineering,
working women,
Hispanics,
STEM education

Reader Comments Read all comments (4)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

WOW - I thought opinions like MCDUDERSON had died with the dinosaurs. While it's true that overt prejudice has diminished, subtle prejudice still exists. Women colleagues of mine report professors who tell them they don't have what it takes to earn a doctorate (and then they prove their old profs wrong). Subtle, yet strong, erroneous messages bombard women and minorities throughout their lives that they don't have what it takes. And these messages take their toll. It can't just be relegated to history.

Jim of TX 7:03PM March 14, 2012

It is absurd in this day and age to think any of the young generation of scientists or engineers are trying to "keep out" women or minorities. A much larger cause is simply there being fewer role-models of these social groups due to historic under-representation. This is no fault of the new generation of STEM workers who aren't women or minorities, but instead the fault of the women and minorities of past generations for not marketing their positions to those from their same social groups and leading the way for interest in these fields for those who otherwise wouldn't have been as interested. The time has come for bootstraps to be pulled upon.

McDuderson of MN 7:11PM October 31, 2011

The whites have had the best schools and colleges for decades and have failed to be competitive globally. The Asians are kicking your Arses! That is why we are importing engineers by the thousands from china and India. Yeah, keep the minorities and women out of STEM.

Art of NV 6:37PM October 28, 2011

STEM Education

Welcome to U.S. News's STEM Education resource center. Here, you'll find the latest news, opinions and thoughts about science, technology, engineering and math education. Also browse viewpoints from top experts in the field, rankings of top STEM schools, and stories about programs and people that are making a difference. We welcome community interaction; please send any news or submissions to stem@usnews.com.

advertisement

Advanced Placement math and science courses provide rigorous training for college, and these 250 schools excel in preparing students with technical skills.

Best High Schools for STEM Rankings

U.S. News STEM Leadership Hall of Fame

Richard B. Alley

Evan Pugh Professor of Geosciences Penn State

Mary L. Good

Special Adviser to the Chancellor for Economic Development University of Arkansas-Little Rock

Freeman A. Hrabowski III

President University of Maryland--Baltimore County

Tom Luce

Chairman National Math + Science Initiative

Ray Mellado

Chairman & CEO Great Minds in STEM

STEM Resources

These organizations and companies have shown a dedicated interest to improving STEM education in America. Want to add your organization? E-mail stem@usnews.com

STEMConnector

A vast resource center for anyone interested in STEM--has profiles and descriptions of thousands of STEM education organizations.

Carnegie Corporation of New York

This hundred-year-old organization provides grants to do "real and permanent good in this world."

Change the Equation

A consortium of more than 100 companies dedicated to transforming STEM education in America.

Dow Chemical Foundation

One of the world's largest chemical manufacturers, Dow's philanthropic arm tries to open students' eyes to STEM career opportunities.

Intel Foundation

The computing giant's foundation runs the world's most important science fair.

Related Articles