STEM Education

  • Comment (3)

STEM Heavily Featured in New 'No Child' Legislation

October 13, 2011 RSS Feed Print

After months of prodding from President Obama and Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, it looks like Congress is finally getting around to reworking the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, more popularly known as No Child Left Behind, the much-maligned law that has governed K-12 education since it went into effect in early 2002.

For the past several months, Obama and Duncan have asked Congress to rework the law, which has been extended on a year-to-year basis since it expired in 2007. The administration has even granted waivers to states that exempt them from parts of the law. In March, Duncan told Congress that more than 80 percent of schools could miss testing benchmarks set by the law, and in June he called the law a "slow-motion train wreck."

Yesterday, Democratic Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin introduced an 860-page bill to that would finally revise the act. Here's the rundown on parts of the proposed law that would affect STEM education.

The bill seeks to fulfill four goals when it comes to STEM:

- Improving instruction in STEM subjects through grade 12

- Improving student engagement in and their access to STEM courses

- Improving the quality of STEM teachers by recruiting and training new teachers as well as improving existing teachers

- Closing the achievement gap between minority and white students and preparing more students for college in STEM subjects

These goals were outlined in legislation introduced last week by Democratic Sens. Jeff Merkley of Oregon, Al Franken of Minnesota, Mark Begich of Alaska, and Kirsten Gillibrand of New York and were woven into the Harkin bill.

States receiving grants for STEM would be required to report extensive data, such as STEM teacher evaluations, student achievement in the subjects, rates of access to STEM classes, achievement gaps, and the percentage of students participating in advanced placement or International Baccalaureate STEM courses.

States would be allowed greater leeway to distribute funds earmarked for STEM, as long as they are used to increase access to STEM courses, implement high-quality STEM programs, provide professional development for teachers, or provide technical assistance to schools.

James Brown, executive director of the STEM Education Coalition, a group made up of STEM organizations that worked with Senator Merkley on drafting the legislation, says the bill "covers the gamut of all the different STEM needs."

The bill specifically allows states to use funds to woo engineers, scientists, and other STEM professionals who could potentially be interested in transitioning to a career in teaching and places an emphasis on spending money on STEM programs that have been proven to work.

"It's a relatively small [amount of research], but there's a growing knowledge base of what works in STEM education and what doesn't," he says. "It's about making sure you're spending taxpayer money effectively."

Although the reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act has been a controversial, partisan issue for much of the year, Brown says STEM is an issue that has bipartisan support.

"It's a tough sell to reauthorize No Child Left Behind, but I think a lot of cynics in Washington didn't think it'd get to this point," he says. "We feel like the STEM focus is very bipartisan and it reflects a lot of agreement between the parties."

For some light reading, check out the entire bill here, or see what the introducing senators have to say about STEM education.

Have something to share? Send news and submissions to stem@usnews.com.

Corrected on 10/13/11: An earlier version of this article misidentified Sen. Begich's home state.

Tags:
No Child Left Behind,
STEM education

Reader Comments Read all comments (3)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Advancements in science and technology have brought tremendous developments in the world and human lives. The word science which derived from the Latin word “scientia” means knowledge.

For more information:

http://www.schoolanduniversity.com/study-programs/sciences

sciences of KS 5:14AM August 01, 2012

This bill does not strengthen the STEM pathway.

A. It is too diffuse: it targets all grades.

B. It is only for high-poverty school districts.

C. The professional development (PD) that it requires for STEM teachers is inadequate; it is only "to enable teachers and instructional leaders to increase student achievement in identified subjects, through—(I) implementation of classroom assessments; and (II) differentiation of instruction. "(p.457) It omits the most important PD: discipline-specific content with instruction on how to teach that content at that grade level. Teaching method is the most important factor in student learning! Evidence is at http://timssvideos.com and http://modeling.asu.edu.

Regarding A. Research points to high school physics as the chief STEM pathway and literacy pathway, so it should be targeted (with chemistry & physical science; they are hardest to staff and are foundations of technology & engineering).

(1) A student who completes a physics course in high school is twice as likely to earn a STEM bachelor's degree as a student whose highest science course is chemistry (Tyson et al., 2007).

(2) Reform high school physics programs almost double again the number of students who intend to major in STEM, compared to conventional lecture-based high school physics (TIMSS, 2000). On TIMSS science & math literacy tests, physics reform programs score highest in the world!

In this bill, states would allocate funds directly to high-need school districts to arrange for their own resources - rather than a consistent, strategic, systemic approach. Few school districts, let alone high-need school districts, have enough teachers of the physical sciences to support professional development (PD) for them; and school districts are ill-equipped to conduct the necessary PD on their own because they lack expertise in science and technology as well as resources to keep up to date on science curriculum and pedagogy. These intellectual resources reside in universities, chiefly in science departments.

REFERENCES:

TIMSS Physics Achievement Comparison Study, by Eugenio Gonzalez (April 2000). Conducted for the National Science Foundation by TIMSS International Study Center, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, MA. http://modeling.asu.edu/Evaluations/TIMSS_NSFphysicsStudy99.pdf

Tyson, W., Lee, R., Borman, K.M., & Hanson, M.A. (2007). Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Pathways: High School Science and Math Coursework and Postsecondary Degree Attainment, Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk, Vol. 12, No. 3, pp. 243-270.

Jane Jackson of AZ 10:07PM October 17, 2011

With respect to curricula, there are two approaches to science education. One approach, the teaching of science facts, is the most common and is the one used by textbook companies. With this approach students learn about the knowledge produced by science but have no exposure to the methodology that produced these facts.

The process skills approach emphasizes the methods and skills used to obtain the facts. This method is used in project based learning and is very successful in stimulating student engagement.

Teacher training should place more in resourses into showing teachers how to combine science facts with project based learning and science skills to create curricula that engages the students.

David Vessell of IN 6:41PM October 17, 2011

STEM Education

Welcome to U.S. News's STEM Education resource center. Here, you'll find the latest news, opinions and thoughts about science, technology, engineering and math education. Also browse viewpoints from top experts in the field, rankings of top STEM schools, and stories about programs and people that are making a difference. We welcome community interaction; please send any news or submissions to stem@usnews.com.

advertisement

Advanced Placement math and science courses provide rigorous training for college, and these 250 schools excel in preparing students with technical skills.

Best High Schools for STEM Rankings

U.S. News STEM Leadership Hall of Fame

Richard B. Alley

Evan Pugh Professor of Geosciences Penn State

Mary L. Good

Special Adviser to the Chancellor for Economic Development University of Arkansas-Little Rock

Freeman A. Hrabowski III

President University of Maryland--Baltimore County

Tom Luce

Chairman National Math + Science Initiative

Ray Mellado

Chairman & CEO Great Minds in STEM

STEM Resources

These organizations and companies have shown a dedicated interest to improving STEM education in America. Want to add your organization? E-mail stem@usnews.com

STEMConnector

A vast resource center for anyone interested in STEM--has profiles and descriptions of thousands of STEM education organizations.

Carnegie Corporation of New York

This hundred-year-old organization provides grants to do "real and permanent good in this world."

Change the Equation

A consortium of more than 100 companies dedicated to transforming STEM education in America.

Dow Chemical Foundation

One of the world's largest chemical manufacturers, Dow's philanthropic arm tries to open students' eyes to STEM career opportunities.

Intel Foundation

The computing giant's foundation runs the world's most important science fair.

Related Articles