Daycare Could Make Your Kid a Brat, But What Are the Alternatives?

March 29, 2007 RSS Feed Print

This comes to us from U.S. News Editorial Assistant Amy Golod:

Children who spend at least 10 hours a week in day care are more likely to be troublemakers at school even through sixth grade, the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development announced in a study this week.

But the reliance of American couples on child care is not set to decrease, so what's to be done about this matter isn't so simple. The Department of Labor projects the rate of enrollment for children under 5 in day care services to grow at a faster rate through 2014 than in years past.

The number of women to enter the work force is also expected to increase, the Labor Department study indicates, furthering the need for such services when families continue to depend on two incomes.

But Kathleen Gerson, professor of sociology at New York University, tells the News Desk that the findings are not completely "clear cut," especially since the study noted that the unruly behavior was within a normal range for healthy children.

"Children are reared by working mothers despite the efforts to find discouraging consequences that it is harmful to them," Gerson said. "We need to focus on how to create communities that are better for children beyond just day care."

"[The study] shoots arrows of guilt into the hearts of parents rather than into all of our hearts for not having better child care," added Barrie Thorne, professor of sociology and women’s studies at the University of California-Berkeley.

The study also found that students who received high quality care had stronger vocabulary scores in fifth grade than those with poorer care.

Etc.: Day Care News: Parents, You Count Most, on USNews.com

Reader Comments Read all comments (1)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

It's always the daycare fault. It could never be that the parents had anything to do with the chidlrens upbringing.

When they are sick, it came from the datcare, IT could never be that even through parents are informed that sick children are not allowed in daycare, they bring them anyhow.

Nightmares!!! something must have happened in daycare!

It's about time people put blame where blame belongs.

Parents have to work. Children are brought into this world by those parents. Most can't afford for one to stay home.

I run a home daycare. I have for 17 years. My son is autistic and was turned away from daycare. So I got out of the Navy after 12 years, and opened a family daycare. I'm licensed, belong to several organization that work to improve daycare, and attend classes towards a degree in early education.

Not all daycare providers are monsters!

Fran of VA 8:45AM January 09, 2009

News Desk