Catholic Kathleen Sebelius and Abortion Politics

March 11, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (4)

By Dan Gilgoff, God & Country

I've got a story up on usnews.com—originally published in Friday's digital U.S. News Weekly—on Kathleen Sebelius's nomination to head the Department of Health and Human Services, showing how abortion/religion politics have been turned upside down in the past five years. I compare John Kerry's failed effort to counter attacks from conservative Roman Catholics and antiabortion groups in 2004 with the successful Democratic efforts to fend off similar attacks on Sebelius:

A Democratic nominee to a national post attempts to project a culturally conservative image, claiming to be a committed Roman Catholic who personally opposes abortion. But conservative Catholic groups call that religious commitment into question. The Democrat's local bishop publicly criticizes the nominee's abortion stance, opening a gap between the purported believer and the Catholic Church. Antiabortion groups launch a campaign to show that, despite the nominee's "personal opposition" to abortion, a record of votes supporting abortion rights suggests otherwise. Can the Democratic nominee's image as a cultural moderate survive?

It depends on which Democrat you're talking about.

In 2004, John Kerry, a former altar boy, withered under attacks from conservative Catholics and antiabortion groups. He lost the Catholic vote, a dramatic turnabout from the previous Catholic nominee for president, John F. Kennedy, who won about 80 percent of Catholics.

Now comes Kathleen Sebelius, the pro-abortion rights Catholic Democrat whom Barack Obama named this week to run the Department of Health and Human Services. Early indications are she is holding up a lot better under harsh criticism from her own bishop, conservative Catholics, and antiabortion groups, who viewed her nomination as their best chance yet to throw a wrench in the White House's liberal social agenda. Instead, Republican leaders have mostly refused to attack Sebelius, even as their base vents outrage over the "pro-abortion zealot." The contrast between the Kerry and Sebelius experiences shows how the politics of abortion and religion has been turned upside down as of late. Democrats have grown increasingly savvy about navigating "values" terrain, while Republicans have gone wobbly on ground they've long held.

Read the full story at usnews.com.

Tags:
Kathleen Sebelius,
abortion,
religion

Reader Comments Read all comments (4)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

If it becomes accepted that Catholic public officials must follow the dictates of the Vatican wrt their public office (not just their personal lives), a notion that JFK had dispelled at one point, then non-Catholics will not vote for any Catholics to be in public office, and righty so. Public officials must serve the whole populace, not just Catholics. It saddens me that Catholic bishops insist on telling US government what to do by ordering Catholic public officials ho they must conduct their public office, undoing what JFK ran on.

Keep it up, if you don't any non-Catholc votes.

One more thing: The Catholic Church is against the death penalty, yet Catholic bishop do NOT deny communion to Catholic Republican public officials that favor and carry out the death penalty. That is total hypocrisy, and hypocrisy is one of the worst sins that there is, according to Jesus's teachings.

Pepe of WA 4:56AM March 30, 2009

The appointment of Sebelius is one more slap in the face orchestrated by the Obama administration and directed at the Catholic church, orthodox monotheists and those opposed to a platform that constitutes an abysmal failure of human compassion towards the most innocent members of society. The appointment is consistent with this administration's disregard for human life, further demonstrated by the dissolution of the Mexico City policy and subsequent funding for embryonic stem cell research. The late pope John Paul II courageously and clearly articulated this downwardly spiraling morass of evil, calling our culture a "Culture of Death" which indeed it is.

The American people, particularly those affiliated with an exponentially expanding federal government along with a gaggle of social engineers, refuse to recognize that America's problems are not simply economic or political. In fact, they are symptomatic of a much greater crisis. We are a morally bankrupt nation and most certainly will collapse beneath the weight of our reprehensible misdeeds.

Much maligned and often ridiculed, fundamentalist Christians have one particular charism in their court. They call sin sin and adamantly pronounce that the only remedy for America is a radical repentance or complete departure from repugnant acts that systematically destroy the most innocent of human life. They are correct.

God may be ignored or portrayed as mythological, refuted to be mere whimsy; a teddy bear in the sky or perhaps a doting granddaddy. God may be crafted as an anachronism to be largely ignored by the illuminati, or God may be defined as whatever it is that makes people comfortable. God will be mimicked by imposters, maligned by the blasphemous and mocked by the arrogant. Ultimately God will prevail.

As regards this administration, its actions thus far and its intentions, the hope and change rhetoric espoused prior to the election illustrate an amazing propensity to influence voters while the works themselves resemble something more akin to smoke and mirrors, a grand delusion.

Prudent Americans would do well to pray for America, not that America will be delivered from the impending dissolution of a once great nation. Rather that those who pray may express their confidence in the One who alone deserves their adoration. Our current executive branch hardly deserves our accolades.

J.M. Palvado of AL 11:13PM March 12, 2009

Sebelius is not pro-abortion. A few weeks ago you had an article about people not wanting to be call the religious right. She is pro-choice or a realist.

16 yrs Reagan + Bush 2, plus a Republian Congress.

Time to face reality - Republicans are all talk and very successful at fooling people about the abortion issue.

Julie of CO 10:02AM March 12, 2009

God & Country

Dan Gilgoff covers religion for U.S. News & World Report. He is the author of The Jesus Machine: How James Dobson, Focus on the Family, and Evangelical America are Winning the Culture War, and is a former politics editor at beliefnet. E-mail Dan at godandcountry@usnews.com.

advertisement