Diane Ravitch: Charter Schools Won't Save the School System

April 19, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (16)

Charter schools won't save the American school system, says Diane Ravitch, a historian of education at New York University who worked in the first Bush administration as assistant secretary of education.

In her new book, The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education, Ravitch argues that charter schools do little more than skim off the most motivated students, while giving crooks a chance to squander tax dollars on big salaries for administrators.

What schools need now, Ravitch says, is a return to a curriculum that includes American history, civics, art, and music rather than the current obsession with skills testing.

U.S. News & World Report's Kenneth Terrell talked with Ravitch about what's gone wrong with American schools, and what kind of leadership is needed to get the schools back on track.

Here's Diane Ravitch on leadership in school reform:

Listen Now: Diane Ravitch: Charter Schools Won't Save the School System

[Click here to listen to the interview with Ravitch.]

The U.S. News podcast series, Leadership for the Next Decade, explores the ideas, innovations, and solutions that will inspire America for the future. Moderated by U.S. News Editor Brian Kelly, the podcasts feature exclusive interviews with leaders across the spectrum, from education, business, art, science, and medicine to government, public service, and philanthropy.

America's Best Leaders 2009

Tags:
charter schools,
education reform,
education,
education policy

Reader Comments Read all comments (16)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I am a current teacher in the Mississippi Delta and technology will be a key component in the future success of my students. We must incorporate technology into teaching higher-order thinking skills which will prepare my students to be today’s learners and tomorrow’s leaders.

You can help my students break their cycle of poverty, a main problem is that they are not given the resources to do so. Please help!

http://www.donorschoose.org/donors/proposal.html?id=374608&sharebar=true

Mr. B of MS 10:11AM April 27, 2010

First, thanks Mandy Cat. :)

I just wanted to suggest that rather than arguing about who is or is not responsible for public education's deficiencies or who should or should not be responsible for correcting them henceforth, perhaps ALL of us need to be taking responsibility. I actually saw Diane Ravitch speak at Stanford, and that was one of the messages I took from it. Surely even the most conservative of Ravitch's critics approve of bringing personal responsibility to bear in creating solutions to problems.

I encourage those of you who reject Ravitch's position out of hand (and perhaps without even reading her book) to see her speak if you have the opportunity. You can get a feel for Diane Ravitch "live" by reading this reflection: http://kl.am/Ravitch

Kenni Smith of CA 6:40PM April 21, 2010

in Our age of computers (and I recommend Edubuntu Linux for far better and cheap or free software) gives us the ability to let those who can go as fast as they need and those who need more help, More time to get help from the instructor. Of course if they are laptops and they go home with your child you may not want them to have on-board web-cams or mikes because with everybody spying on everybody a problem could arise(don't ask for trouble).

education and health care should be thought of as one subject because as in my cases a doctor can make a educators job much harder, The teacher needs a voice with the doctor or active parent in many cases but in my days that is not the way things were done.

Don D. Brock

Don D. Brock of AZ 4:42PM April 21, 2010

advertisement

Methodology

Choosing America's Best Leaders 2009

America's Best Leaders is a collaboration between U.S.News & World Report and the Center for Public Leadership at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government.

COMMENTARY: David Gergen

The National Deficit—of Leadership

President Obama fired the imagination of the country during his campaign, but the glow has faded.

COMMENTARY: MICHELLE OBAMA

The Future Lies in Teachers

Having good teachers in classrooms is critical because education is the road to opportunity, the first lady writes.

advertisement