China, Russia Stealth Nipping at U.S. Heels, Officials Say

Experts question the relevance of F-35 in America’s next war.


An F-35B test aircraft BF completes an aerial weapons release, dropping a 1,000-pound GBU-32 Joint Direct Attack Munition over the Atlantic Ocean from an internal weapons bay.

By + More

Pentagon officials say "countries of concern" such as China and Russia are close to having weapons that can compete with America's latest stealth fighter jets.

But experts in the field question the hundreds of billions of dollars the government has poured into programs it says are essential for America's security.

[ALSO: North Korea Is Still a Top Threat, Pentagon Says]

"We can't ignore the advancement in technologies that our major countries of concern have out there in the world today," Marine Corps Col. Kevin Killea tells U.S. News. The head of the Corps' Aviation Weapons Requirements branch says fifth-generation aircraft, such as the F-35B Lightning II, will be critical if the military wants to keep up on overseas threats in the next decade.

"If you're not fifth-generation, that's the ticket to play," he says. "That's the price of admission in that fight. If you don't have a capability that is at least equal to or better than them, you're not going to last very long."

"We need to evolve. Our enemy is evolving," adds Marine Gen. Matthew Glavy, assistant deputy commandant for Aviation. "It goes back to out-pacing and out-tempoing your enemy."

"You have to be paranoid. That's what we're paid to do," he adds.

The F-35 Joint Strike Fighter program is now considered the single most expensive weapons program in the history of the military. This is largely due to cost overruns spurred on by the military's desire to have one airplane with versions for the Marine Corps, Air Force and Navy – all of which have different requirements for a fighter.

Killea is excited by what the F-35 will bring to the Marine Corps as it continues a "rebalance to the Pacific."

"Forget about the fact that it's stealth," he says. "What this airplane is going to do is give incredible situational awareness to everybody on the ground, everybody flying other airplanes around it that are networked into it…and don't forget the ship it came from, and the forward arms and refueling points."

Killea uses the analogy of roadside radar detection to explain the kind of information a fifth-generation fighter can gather. A simple radar detector can just tell a driver there is a radar gun nearby. An advanced system would be able to determine where the radar detector is, how far away it is and how to evade it.

"It not only locates threat systems, it identifies them and tells the guy in the F-35 where not to go and where to go," he says.

This network of information could then be distributed to other aircraft such as the CH-53K Super Stallion, variants of the H-1 helicopter and the new MV-22 Osprey.

[MORE: Marines to Test MV-22 Air-to-Air Refueling this Summer]

Killea points to China, Russia and India's focus on developing their own versions of a fifth-generation fighter.

"We have been pretty smart about the way we've adapted real time, but we've never lost sight…on not fighting the last fight and looking forward to what we need to do to be credible in the next fight," he says.

But one expert in Asian security says these concerns might be aimed at paper tigers.

Tom Snitch, a security consultant, used to be a senior advisor for nuclear and weapons control policy at the U.S. Arms Control and Disarmament Agency. He has spent much of the last 20 years studying the military assets of Russia and China, including seeing MiGs fighter jets "up close."

"It's hard for me to believe they are developing a capability that is costing us a billion dollars a plane to have the same attributes and capabilities," he tells U.S. News. "The Chinese and Russians are decades behind us in this technology."

The Marine version of the F-35, which includes a second engine to allow it to land vertically, will cost just under $240 million each, though the overall cost of developing the program exceeds $1 trillion, according to some estimates.

[SEE: Iranian Agents Prop Up Assad From Within Syria, Report Says]

Snitch questions the kind of scenario in which the U.S. would get into a dogfight with another country.

And if the goal is simply to provide an intelligence hub, that could be provided more safely and cheaply with a network of drones or modifying existing fighters like the F-16.