It started with a remark from Vice President Joe Biden--or maybe it didn't--but regardless of when or how, the 2012 presidential campaign has now become fully engulfed in racial politics.
Some experts say it's inevitable when you have a candidate of one race pitted against a candidate from another, but the racial themes emerging in the race between President Barack Obama and Republican hopeful Mitt Romney may go deeper than just a gaffe.
The Obama campaign has been on defense since Biden claimed earlier this week before a mixed-race audience that Romney's push to repeal the financial regulation law known as Dodd-Frank amounted to his intention to put "y'all back in chains." Observers on both sides of the aisle found the remarks offensive and Biden later said he meant to use another word. In an interview, Obama himself said the "phrasing is a distraction from what's at stake."
The Romney campaign and fellow GOP-ers were quick to cry foul, and the candidate himself seemed to take personal offense to Biden's dig. In an extended campaign speech, Romney told supporters "this is what an angry and desperate presidency looks like," suggesting Obama should "take your campaign of division and anger and hate back to Chicago."
It was his repeated use of the term "angry" that led some to believe he was using semi-coded language to gin up his base against the "angry black man" in the White House.
"You notice he said anger twice; he's really trying to use racial coding and access some really deep stereotypes about the angry black man," said Toure, an African-American co-host on MSNBC's The Cycle, on Thursday. "This is part of the playbook against Obama, the 'otherization,' he's not like us," he continued. "I know it's a heavy thing, I don't say it lightly, but this is 'niggerization.' You are not one of us, you are like the scary black man who we've been trained to fear."
Neither the Romney campaign nor the Obama campaign responded to request for comment on the possible racial undertones of Romney's speech.
Politicos and analysts contacted about the war of words were mixed on whether or not they saw racially coded language by Romney. One Republican said it was in no way meant to conjure the image of an angry black man and former Virginia Democratic Gov. Douglas Wilder, who condemned Biden's remarks, says he "didn't see anything racial" in what Romney said.
"It could be construed, but I didn't see it," Wilder says. "He's not the most precise person. It was a moment of frustration."
Ron Bonjean, a GOP political consultant in Washington, says Romney was obviously fired up by Biden's rhetoric.
"The incivility came quickly to the forefront with the comments by Joe Biden, which caused such a negative reaction from Mitt Romney, who took it rather personally," he says. "It was an instant reaction from Romney, it was a visceral reaction. You don't see much emotion from Romney on the campaign trail and it might not be a bad thing for him to show some reactive behavior."
Bonjean says the Romney camp knows the president is the more well-liked candidate and is merely trying to even the playing field.
"It's an attempt to take Obama's likability down a notch or two by calling him out on the words of his vice president," he says.
Zerlina Maxwell, a Democratic strategist and political analyst, says the Romney campaign has exhibited a series of racially charged actions.
"There are a lot of things on the other side that are ongoing," she says. "It's almost because it happens so often it doesn't become a newsworthy story and then the one-off 'chain' thing becomes a weeklong story."