Ralph Nader Calls for Ending Athletic Scholarships

March 24, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (2)

WASHINGTON— Consumer advocate Ralph Nader is calling for the elimination of college athletic scholarships, saying the move is necessary to "de-professionalize" college athletes.

Nader's League of Fans, a group aimed at reforming sports, proposes that the scholarships be replaced with need-based financial aid. He says that would help restore academic integrity to college sports. [See U.S. News's exclusive rankings of colleges and universities.]

The Associated Press obtained a copy of the proposal Thursday, ahead of its official release. [See which members of Congress get the most money from education interests.]

Nader, a former presidential candidate, argues that his plan would also help reduce the "win-at-all-costs" mentality in high schools, by reducing the incentive of college scholarships.

Tags:
Ralph Nader

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

"....some coaches are earning five to 10 times what is paid to their schools' president. He advocates a hard salary cap on coaches' pay, although he admits getting approval for one would be difficult."

"If the NCAA were to place, say, a $400,000 cap on coaches' compensation packages -- about five times an assistant professor's pay, which would also put coaches' pay in line with the average pay of college presidents -- it would not materially affect the quality of coaching or the college programs' ability to attract top talent," Zimbalist wrote".

It is obsene to spend $5 million on a football coach when the school does not have the funds for academic scholarships or true professors who are there to actally educate students. And imagine what big schools spend on all their coaching stff - football, basketball, baseball, soccer, swimming, etc...

Zimbalist is right - the caches would coach even with a slaary cap as long a they didn't think someone else was getting better. Maybe the school would make MORE money, and instead of spending it on jacuzzis for sore knees, they would divert those funds to poor students looking for a break on insanely high tuitions. Or maybe they could divert the millions to the elementary schools so we wouldn't have to cut public schools.

College sport is WAY out of line. Kids don't go to college to study - and all the faciltities, fuel and crepe paper create mountains of waste, huge operating budgets spent on anything but learning, cheerleaders who spend their time learning how shake it instead of how to shake it up and THINK. Our competition (China , Europe, Japan, Australia, Canada take all those big programs OUT of the schools. People join clubs that are not part of the university. ENough of the semi-pro deal in college. The professional football league uses the unversities as their farm leagues where players risk their health and most never graduate and most never play in the pros either -and they do it all for free! At least MLB has the decenc to invest in farm leagues....

Nader is right, but this country can only think of its entertainment and TV revenues. The colleges are being used by big money - and the public of course buys in....

DeeToo of SC 6:11PM March 24, 2011

OK first time posting EVER. Ralph Nader has the WRONG idea about scholarships. It is how the youths from disenfranchised areas "POOR" were able to make better lives for both themselves and their families and friends. All races of humanity benefit from the scholarships that allows the student to move forward both in class and status. Without these scholarships the world will lose some serious advancements for the human race. The scholarships need to be changed so that the students have to be both academically and physically superior to be considered. As a brother of someone who had a 110 mph fast ball at age 14 I know what I am talking about. He was scouted by some of the biggest names in recruiting only to have it all taken away by a carjacking that left him with a bullet in his neck to close to the spine to be operated on BEFORE he was awarded the sports scholarship that everyone knew he should have received. He did however go on to a community college and graduated with honors. Not the ivy league school he was supposed to attend with his sports scholarship. Without the scholarship he never would have been able to go to Pepperdine University. But alas this did not happen. Taking away scholarships denies the youth of today the opportunity to escape the poverty level that they might currently be in.

Jerry Thompson of NV 5:27PM March 24, 2011

Photo Galleries

Women on Death Row

Only 12 women have been executed on death row in the U.S. since 1976.

advertisement

Latest Videos