Homeland Security Tops FOIA Requests List

The Defense Department receives the second largest number of requests

March 18, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (2)

One of Barack Obama's first promises as president was to make his the most transparent administration in history. This week, the obama administration became more transparent with the Justice Department's launch of FOIA.gov, a website that provides data about requests made under the Freedom of Information Act. The FOIA request is a common tool of journalists, scholars, and government watchdog groups, as well as average citizens who are curious about the inner workings of government agencies. The Freedom of Information Act states that the government must provide any requested information that is not protected by law. According to FOIA.gov, the government received 597,415 FOIA requests in FY 2010, with just three departments accounting for nearly half of those requests.

Data from FOIA.gov shows that the Department of Homeland Security received one-fifth of all FOIA requests in fiscal year 2010 (a period covering October 2009 through September 2010), with over 130,000 requests. Homeland Security records of FOIA requests show inquiries into past FOIA case logs, complaints filed by Immigration and Customs Enforcement detainees, and a classified evaluation of airport screening checkpoint effectiveness. The Defense Department is next, with 73,573 requests--just over half the total requests of Homeland Security. Many Defense FOIA requests pertained to information about the department's contractors, but other requests yielded correspondence and memos written by past top officials, including former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld and former Vice President Dick Cheney. The Department of Health and Human Services received the third most FOIA requests in 2010, with nearly 64,000. An overwhelming majority of Health and Human Services requests in fiscal year 2010 (46,856) were to the department's Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

The FOIA.gov launch comes during Sunshine Week, an initiative that promotes government transparency. The Florida Society of Newspaper Editors instituted the non-partisan, nonprofit effort in 2002, and the cause is now led by the American Society of News Editors, with significant support from organizations that support journalism, like the Knight Foundation and the Gridiron Club

Below are the 10 federal departments and agencies that received the most FOIA requests in fiscal year 2010.

Department/Agency Requests Received (FY10) 
Department of Homeland Security 130,098
Department of Defense 73,573
Department of Health and Human Services 63,839
Department of Justice 63,682
Social Security Administration 32,997
Department of State 30,206
Department of Veterans' Affairs 29,127
Department of Agriculture 20,368
Department of Labor 17,398
Department of the Treasury 16,911

The Freedom of Information Act states that within 20 working days of receiving a request, an agency must decide whether to comply and then respond to the requester. Requests not answered within that time frame are considered backlogged. The State Department is at the top of the list of agencies and departments with unanswered requests, with 20,519--more than two-thirds the number of requests it received in fiscal year 2010. However, requests can be backlogged for years or even for more than a decade; some FOIA requests from the 1990s are still pending.

Department/Agency Backlogged Requests as of End of FY10 
Department of State 20,519
Department of Homeland Security 11,383
Department of Health and Human Services 9,552
Department of Defense 7,657
National Archives and Records Administration 7,064
Department of Justice 5,160
Department of Agriculture 1,136
Department of Transportation 787
Central Intelligence Agency 715
Department of the Interior 679

Despite the administration's push for greater transparency, some argue that the handling of FOIA requests must be further improved. Vermont Democratic Sen. Patrick Leahy and Texas Republican Sen. John Cornyn, two longtime advocates of government openness, re-introduced the Faster FOIA Act this week, a bill they first introduced in 2005. The measure would establish a panel to examine FOIA request backlogs and find ways reduce processing delays. In a statement released today, Cornyn said that such a panel "would be a great benefit to the American people, who deserve to be treated as valued customers when they seek answers from their government."

Tags:
Dick Cheney,
John Cornyn,
Donald Rumsfeld,
Republican Party,
Pat Leahy,
national security terrorism and the military,
Democratic Party,
Barack Obama

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

In the wake of so many reports of Fusion Center abuses and the engagement of millions to stalk, harass and torture innocent civilians; I would see why the Department of Homeland Security and Dept. of Justice would be inundated with FOIA Requests. Our world has change; changed for the worse. Government agencies and government contractor base has become enormous, with one of the top government contractors earning as much as 750 TRILLION per year in development of human satellite tracking and direct energy weaponry which has unfortunately been placed in the hands of Fusion Center and local police, and for what...to fight terrorist, NO - to cause harm to innocent civilians in order to maintain the trillions of funding from the government. FOIA, yes. Read The Washington Post report on 'A Top Secret America' to lean more. And we wonder why the United States is hated so. If you would torture your own citizens, why would you not torture and experiment on Third-World countries as well. May God Have Mercy on Us All.

FOIA YES...

DMiles of OH 12:59PM March 22, 2011

The USCIS website has links for genealogy requests. In March 2010 I sent in an index search request in with $20 per person for a search and I included World War II alien registration numbers for my parents, and other numbers I had found in the NARA files.

After a half a year I got the response that USCIS had found one item in their index for my father which I ordered for $20 and have received. They found two documents for my mother, the alien registration and a naturalization document. I sent in $55. for these but have never received them [now in March 2011]. I have sent emails to inquire, but there is no response.

It would be a great boon to genealogists to make the alien registration records of World War I and II available as images on line, and with a search available by AR-number and by name.

The same would be even more true of the World War II enemy alien registration files, which contain more personal information.

F Allen of OH 7:59PM March 18, 2011

Photo Galleries

Storms, Wildfires Tear Across U.S.

Heavy rain, high winds and fire continue to plague regions throughout the country.

advertisement

Latest Videos