Home > News > Why Congress Is Unlikely to Bail Out Detroit’s Carmakers—at Least for Now

Why Congress Is Unlikely to Bail Out Detroit’s Carmakers—at Least for Now

Reader Comments
Back to article

No Bailout! Our society in it's infinite wisdom has removed the process of social Natural Selection. And now some what to remove it from free market enterprise.
Once upon a time, if you owned a business but it failed either through poor business practices, bad customer care, poor quality products, etc. you went out of business & a spot was opened for someone else who might possibly do it better. But now, every time a person [homeowners] or businessess [the Big 3] make bad decisions, they want us the tax payers to bail them out! No!!!!
We made a poor real estate decision & had to tighten our belts to pay 2 mortgages until our old house sole. Christmas wasn't real fun for anyone, but Hey...we got ourselves into it & we got ourselves out of it.
Stop propping up the losers! Let them fall flat on their faces for a change & maybe they'll make better choices in the future.

Katie of NM 5:35PM December 05, 2008

How will a bailout help them? They will continue with the same practices under the same management. It hasn't worked and it will not work no matter how much money you throw at them. I believe GM lost 3.2 billion dollars last quarter. If we give them 8 billion dollars (25 billion divided by 3) does that mean they will burn through that in 6-8 months and then be crying broke again. If I wanted to support any of the big three I would have bought one of their products. I chose a foreign car because I got more value for my hard earned money. Now after many years of sub par cars the big three want the American taxpayers to help them, I say no way. Let them file bankruptcy and reorganize and renegotiate their contracts to emerge stronger. The Airline industry does it quite frequently and in most cases it works.
No Bail Out!

Daryl V of IL 12:00PM November 19, 2008

No-no-no! The bailout money was meant for banks, not auto-makers. What would be next, the airlines? Rail industry? Doctors, lawyers, & Indian-Chiefs? Sorry, but we have the business banckruptcy courts for a reason. No, I don't know what to do with all the people who very regretably may be put out of a job, but perhaps they may come out ahead, too, tho I dread seeing that happen! I wish I knew a solution, but I don't. Perhaps some good will come out of this, and we can finally get more fuel-efficient cars, that don't pollute as much (vehicles and industry smokestacks are two of the biggest air-polluters in the world; why have our politicians not put the screws to these polluters and shut 'em down if they can't drastically shape up?! Where were you, the reader of this comment, all these years, not taking time to insist the politicians do just that?!). By the way, still driving that big gas-guzzler? Vehicular heresy, get rid of it this minute!
I work for Wal-Mart (14 & a half years), and I don't think anyone will bail them out if they get in trouble. Of course, they are the biggest retailer of that type in the world. Before anyone criticizes, though, I will be the first one to say that while they have just had another record year, their stock is stagnant, their CEOs, VIPs, & Board of Directors get monstrously huge bonuses, salaries, & benefits each year, while we little hourly workers struggle along on higher benefit premiums, reduced benefits, reduced hours, reduced wage opportunities. Oh, we get some benefits, but not as good as it used to be, there is no job security (we need a union, & I don't even usually like unions!), & we are at the mercy ofr unqualified, unstable management consortiums. But we little hourlies keep plugging along, trying desperately to really take care of our customers, because we really do like them, & feel they deserve our best service we can provide (at least that is my feelings, one who really does respect them). But there will be no bailout for us, no matter what happens. But I digress...
Back to auto-makers (but this applies to all businesses, big corporations down to smaller businesses): when serving the public, you have a duty to provide the very best environment you can for your workers, & the very best products, goods, & services you can to the public, your real employers. When you don't, perhaps to fail & get out of the business is actually the ultimate best service you can provide under the circumstances. Like in Chess, good planning is essential, you may well reap what you sow. Of course there are market forces that could make a difference, & so that brings us back to remedies (Banckruptcy Court). Why reward incompetance? Recently some recipients went on vacations with the bailout money, trips,awarded additional bonuses, went shopping for additional businesses, crying "poor". Well, I cry "Fraud/prosecution!" How about them apples?!
Jim M. Gau
Hancock, MI

Jim of MI 6:35PM November 18, 2008