Coming Soon: $500 for Every Newborn?

Proposed legislation would start every American on a path toward savings

By Kimberly Palmer

Posted: October 6, 2009

Imagine a world where every baby received a trust fund at birth. It might sound like a fairy tale, but being born into money—or at least into a $500 savings account—could soon become reality for all children born in the United States. Lawmakers are considering a bill that would give each newborn just that, with the goal of promoting savings that would later be used for education, a first home, or retirement. Here's what you should know about the ASPIRE ("America Saving for Personal Investment, Retirement, and Education") Act:

[Slide Show: The Top 10 Fall Deals.]

How would this program work?

The ASPIRE Act would give each child born in the United States a $500 savings account. Recipients could then use that money once they were older to pay for education, a first home, or retirement. Low-income children would receive additional funding, and all participants could add to their accounts over time.

Would it really help people save more money? Five hundred dollars isn't much.

The purpose of the accounts, says Reid Cramer, director of the Asset Building Program at the New America Foundation, is to get people invested in their future. "Having an asset has the potential to change the way people think and plan for their future, and sometimes those effects can be generated just from small asset holdings," he says, adding that it's possible for people to build up significant savings over time. The ASPIRE Act also pairs the creation of the accounts with financial literacy programs in schools.

Indeed, pioneering research by University of Michigan professor Michael Sherraden suggests starting individual savings accounts for lower-income people can lead them to feel more confident about the future. Recipients of such accounts also report feeling that they have greater control over their lives, including the ability to plan for education and retirement costs. Further studies have shown that owning assets is associated with greater empowerment and civic participation, increased income, and positive educational outcomes.

Why not just give the money to low-income people who really need it?

Entitlement programs that benefit everyone, such as Social Security and Medicare, tend to enjoy more widespread support and therefore last longer. Programs aimed exclusively at lower-income groups, such as welfare programs, often attract more controversy and receive less political support.

"The important thing is that everybody gets an account," says Cramer, and that it's opened automatically so families don't need to take much action. It would still be a progressive program, he adds, because as the ASPIRE Act is currently written, poorer families would receive additional funding.

[See also: Credit Card Fees: 5 Things You Should Know.]

Don't we already have a lot of policies in place that encourage savings?

Yes, but they tend to mainly help people with higher incomes. According to Sherraden, two thirds of retirement tax benefits go to households that earn incomes of $100,000 and higher. Policies that encourage homeownership, such as tax deductions on interest payments, similarly benefit those who can already afford to purchase homes. Other savings systems, such as 529 accounts for college savings, depend on parents opening the accounts and making deposits. The ASPIRE Act is different because each child would have an account and receive an initial deposit.

Has this been tried anywhere before?

Yes—in Great Britain. Since September 2002, children born in the United Kingdom have received a $500 savings account, just as the ASPIRE Act would provide in the United States. Recipients can withdraw the money after the age of 18; unlike in the proposed U.S. version, there are no restrictions on how they can spend the money. About one quarter of the recipients add extra money to the account, and, according to calculations by Cramer, most of the accounts go up in value so they are worth over $600. (The money is invested in a diversified portfolio of stocks, much like college savings, or 529, accounts in the United States.) Since the program's first enrollees are now only 7 years old, it's too early to say how they will spend the money once they turn 18.

RFCord

WE KEEP VOTING OUR "POLITICIANS" BACK IN OFFICE YEAR AFTER YEAR. WHY NOT CLEAN HOUSE AND "VOTE" HONEST PEOPLE THAT WILL WATCH OUR COUNTRY AND NOT CONTINUING VOTING THE SAME PEOPLE, OVER, AND OVER, AND OVER. WHO'S TO BLAME, US THE "VOTERS!!!"

RUDY of NM @ Nov 10, 2009 13:33:26 PM

What a joke the reporter of this article is

I want to know how there are Oct comments to this article posted on Nov 6.

The aspire act of 2009 is literally fishy. It has to do with tuna fishing subsidies on the other sideof the world in American Samoa.

The aspire act refered to in the article is not 2009 but 2007 and died two years ago. The same as the fish proposal dis on Nov 4th 2009. Now held in committee with no vote.

Wake up america these unprofession reporters not verifying crap are destroying their own credibility as well as america. It is not the radicals introducing the law too years ago. It is the radicals trying to sway your opinion by atributing it to others today. Who cares what happened in legislation two years ago. We have enough current problems.

J Markey of FL @ Nov 10, 2009 06:42:15 AM

MikeC

This gives $500 (of borrowed money from China that is payable with interest) to the banks who can then lend out up to $5,000 based on it (fractional reserve banking). Also, usually any money simply given to someone pushes the cost of the end product up the same way tax credits for 1st -time homebuyers has helped mitigate the fall in housing prices temporarily.

If everyone has one dollar, the guy selling them an apple will get one dollar for the apple. If you give everyone 2 dollars, someone will offer to pay the apple guy 2 dollars. He will then tell the rest of the people that an apple costs $2.

MikeC of NY @ Nov 08, 2009 10:06:28 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

U.S. News Rankings & Research

Best Places

Search for the perfect place for you and your family.

Best Careers

Careers that offer strong outlooks and high job satisfaction.

Car Rankings & Reviews

Make an informed choice when shopping for your next car.

advertisement

Slide Shows

10 Hard-Hit Housing Markets Ready to Rebound

Even with home prices still falling at the national level, a number of markets are gearing up for a rebound.

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!