A Financial Roadmap for Generation Y

For many 20-somethings, downgrading expectations is the best survival strategy

By Kimberly Palmer

Posted: July 21, 2009

In many ways, Pete Mele, a 28-year-old father of two in Queens, N.Y., represents his generation. After he graduated from college with a small amount of debt and got married, he says, he hit a brick wall. Mele and his wife would like to buy a house eventually, but even if they managed to come up with a $20,000 down payment, he says the mortgage would be at least double the rent of their three-bedroom apartment: "At this rate, we'll never have a house—it's just fiscally impossible. So I don't know what to do."

[For more, read: 10 Ways to Thrive After the Recession.]

These days, 20-somethings are not just struggling to pay off student loan debt and coping with rising health insurance costs. They're also fighting to hang on to their jobs. A recent survey by the nonprofit Qvisory found that roughly 1 in 5 young adults between the ages of 18 and 29 is unemployed, compared with a 7 percent unemployment rate for those over age 30. Twenty-somethings are also graduating from college with more debt than their predecessors did and taking jobs that don't always come with health insurance. Half of those surveyed by Qvisory said they've lost health insurance coverage during the past five years, and 2 in 5 said they have skipped meals to save money. "America's younger generation is in jeopardy of not just doing worse than their parents but of spending decades digging themselves out of debt," says Gina Glantz, treasurer at Qvisory.

If you feel like you are among those trapped in debt and struggling to get on top financially, consider these five strategies for shifting your perspective:

Adjust your expectations. Are today's 20- and 30-somethings really that much worse off than their parents and grandparents? Although the challenges facing young people are certainly real, part of the problem is their overblown expectations. In a recent story published in the online magazine Slate, Jennifer, 29, owner of a two-bedroom condo with her husband, worried that she won't be able to have children for at least a decade because she and her husband can't afford to buy a house. Yet in some countries, a two-bedroom condo is considered the height of luxury. The overall rise in homeownership rates, from 55 percent of American households in 1950 to 68 percent today, has probably contributed to the idea that owning a house is an essential part of becoming an adult (and perhaps having children).

[For more, read: "When Young People's High Hopes Create Despair."]

Don't compare yourself to your parents. Beth Kobliner, author of Get a Financial Life: Personal Finance in Your Twenties and Thirties, says she thinks this group is slowly adjusting its expectations, but today's 20-somethings grew up in a time when wealth across the board appeared to be expanding and "people had inflated expectations of what living well means," she says. It's likely that their parents' home values rose along with their investments.

Appreciate what you have. Johanna Miller, 31, of College Park, Md., recently commented on the Alpha Consumer blog that she feels lucky because a scholarship allowed her to avoid student debt and she has a relatively secure job as an editor for an academic publication. Jae Jimenez, a 20-something commenter from Brooklyn, N.Y., says he and his wife are enjoying their frugal lifestyle and that they live with their daughter in a two-bedroom apartment. "We get so tired of hearing people say they have to live in a house once they get married or have a kid. Yes, it would be nice, but it's a luxury . . . . That's ridiculous to have such crazy expectations, especially right now," he wrote.

Steer clear of debt. "I see too many young people choosing to live above their means and on credit," says Nancy Thomas McInnes, 46, a teacher in Gainesville, Fla., who is also a volunteer facilitator for a financial education class. McInnes, an older member of generation X, learned how to manage her money the hard way: Although the only debt she and her husband now carry is their mortgage, they once had roughly $18,000 in credit card debt. "We cringed every time we walked to our mailbox. The fear of what bill might be inside was always present," she says. "Now we use just debit cards and live within our means. A huge burden has been lifted from our shoulders."

[For more, read: "The Future of Social Security: Not Good."]

Get creative with your living arrangements. Judith Copeland, 42, a Web programming student in Nashville, shares a house with her in-laws because she and her husband—who works two jobs—couldn't afford to live on their own with their two children. That kind of creativity might not be ideal, but sometimes it's necessary, as today's 20-somethings are painfully discovering.

I thought Muser was joking!

Muser, your thinking is so far off that you are going to doom the next generations to poverty. You really want to lay your future in the hands of fat cat Washington politicians? As long as everyone has the opportunity to get a good education so s/he can reach the American dream with hard work and sacrifice that should be enough. Perhaps you live in a different country than I but I haven't seen govt work well or not waste billions EVER! As for people with wealth, 80% of American millionaires are first generation rich. That means they EARNED what they have and they shouldn't have to cover you, me, or anyone who didn't strive the way they did. Life is not supposed to be fair. It's supposed to offer opportunity and a safety net (only) for those who have temporary problems. Debt will bring down this country. It will also make people lazy. We didn't become a strong country based on your reasoning and we shall NEVER be strong again as long as people believe they are owed more than the basics. You are not entitled to what the baseball player makes. He is a commodity who brings money in! And he chose to play. He was born with a gift. He also gets taxed higher than you and I and he's one of the ones that keeps this country going so Obama and others like him can spend/waste us into the ground. He owes YOU nothing other than paying his "fair" share of taxes. We need the Fair (consumer) Tax now, but we'll never get it because that would put Washington out of business. If you want the TRUTH about taxes please check out the Tax Foundation's website. Then cry over how much states get for its citizens and then waste! I've worked for state and county govt and the waste along w/the $ that lines the pockets of administrators is DISGUSTING!

FLNonny of FL @ Jul 25, 2009 10:29:15 AM

And what else?

The young people should vote liberal, of course. Nobody but government (via far-left liberals) is going to solve their health care cost problems. We're in the thick of that right now. Press on.

Nobody but liberals in government is going to re-steepen the income tax at the high end either. This is absolutely necessary, of course, so that the federal government is not broke. You think it's okay there in New York for the guy in this article to be stuck in an apartment while A-Rod gets hundreds of millions taxed below 40% to play baseball? And the government is so broke it borrows from China? Are we nuts? It ought to be 80% at that level----so that the excessive compensation of hundreds of millions is not paid in the first place---and you could afford a Yankees ticket.

Muser of NM @ Jul 21, 2009 17:00:56 PM

Positive Financial Illusions

There's a concept in psychology called "positive illusions," which is typically a useful pattern that helps us stay mentally healthy. Basically, people who have positive illusions about themselves and the world are more likely to be optimistic and cheerful rather than pessimistic and depressed.

However, as I point out in my 2008 book No Sucker Left Behind, when it comes to finances, positive illusions can be dangerous. Instead, it's critical for young people to have realistic expectations for their financial future.

Author, No Sucker Left Behind of NY @ Jul 21, 2009 15:55:21 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

U.S. News Rankings & Research

Best Places

Search for the perfect place for you and your family.

Best Careers

Careers that offer strong outlooks and high job satisfaction.

Car Rankings & Reviews

Make an informed choice when shopping for your next car.

advertisement

Slide Shows

10 Hard-Hit Housing Markets Ready to Rebound

Even with home prices still falling at the national level, a number of markets are gearing up for a rebound.

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!