Overrated Career: Professor

By Marty Nemko

Posted: December 11, 2008

The Appeal: After four years, you've got your Ph.D. and get to live a life of the mind on a halcyon campus. You help students to flower and conduct research that will make a difference, while enjoying maximum job security, thanks to lifetime tenure after just seven years. And with the cushy 30-week school year, you have lots of time off.

The Reality: The average total time to a Ph.D. is 10 years. And even a Ph.D. from a prestigious university far from guarantees a tenure-track professorship.

Even if you beat the odds, the professor's life is no picnic:

To get tenure, which takes seven years, one typically must, in addition to a carrying full teaching load and advising students, publish original research, serve on committees, and perform other university service. That means long hours and not even close to getting the summers off.

Even if they get tenure, many professors experience considerable frustration:

The Alternatives: university librarian, program analyst.

Intellect Fighting Over VERY little

I had quite a few jobs prior to becoming a university professor. I can honestly say that I have never had to deal with such vicious, petty, aggressive, obnoxious colleagues at any of my previous jobs. My colleagues are like a bunch of prostitutes squabbling over quarter tips. Funding for everything is always a struggle. My building is filthy, there is no money for even the most basic equipment and supplies and we have had a total of 4% increase in salary over the past five years. We are fighting to keep health insurance. What good is tenure with no benefits? I would not advise anyone to consider a career as a university professor.

Jack Smith of IN @ Nov 12, 2009 22:56:52 PM

Yeah

Anything can be great if you are in the top 1%, if you consistently work your tail off to stay there, and if you are lucky. No surprise there. But we are talking probabilities and we are asking which careers are a cool place to be for most people in those careers.

In sports, it is a no-brainer that while the top one tenth of one percent of boxers make great money for a couple of years, most boxers end up broke, brain damaged, and in pain. Meanwhile, most golfers tend to have long careers and pretty decent lives. Overall, if you want a happy life, your odds are better as a golfer than a boxer. We aren't talking Tyson v. Tiger...we are talking averages.

In careers, if you want a happy life, some careers give better odds than others. That's a no brainer. I'm in an overrated career...but so what, we all have a choice...we don't have to stay where we are.

JS of CA @ Nov 10, 2009 02:37:23 AM

Interesting

Well, some of the article is true. It left out the real positives - when you do get those brilliant, driven, and enjoyable students (especially grad students) and you DO make a difference, and the real negatives - the fact that we really and truly get paid peanuts, especially if you compare us to our colleagues in industry, and that a 60, 70, or 80 hour work week is more the norm than the rarity. I wouldn't do anything else, but my family and social life suffer and have for 10 years now. Not to mention - tenure isn't what it once was, with post-tenure annual reviews now the norm. Research is as much about bringing IN grant dollars as it is putting OUT good product also - bean counters dominate in the academic society.

TiredDoc of WY @ Oct 12, 2009 16:36:30 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

U.S. News Rankings & Research

Best Places

Search for the perfect place for you and your family.

Best Careers

Careers that offer strong outlooks and high job satisfaction.

Car Rankings & Reviews

Make an informed choice when shopping for your next car.

advertisement

Slide Shows

The 10 Best Places to Find a Tech Job

IT service jobs—in engineering and in software services—have fared well in this economy.

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!