Best Careers 2009: Urban Regional Planner

A multi-faceted job for a multi-talented person

By Marty Nemko

Posted: December 11, 2008

Overview. Should a new stadium be built downtown? How can a county reduce sprawl while providing appealing, affordable housing? What should the city demand of a developer who wants to build a new project?

To address questions like these, planners analyze trends, population needs and desires, the area's assets and liabilities, and laws and policies. Planners conduct studies, lead meetings with experts, and hold public hearings.

Before making a recommendation, planners end up wearing many hats: civil engineer, architect, economist, budget analyst, sociologist, and politician. A diplomat's touch is necessary if you expect your plan to survive all of the stakeholders' competing interests.

In larger communities, you might be able to specialize in redeveloping blighted areas; choosing proper land use for a particular parcel; or managing transportation, housing, environmental protection, or historic preservation. In smaller communities, you may handle it all.

A Day in the Life. You're a planner for a rapidly growing small city and, rather than filling the distant suburbs with minimansions, you're eager to redevelop faded urban areas. That approach will require fewer new roads and make better use of existing resources. So, you've solicited proposals from developers and selected one.

Now, the real work begins. Today, you're reviewing geographic information system maps and other computer-based data to predict how many city services will be needed, from lampposts to libraries to fire hydrants. What mix of parking garages, additional bus service, and other transportation should be required? What about plug-in, shared electric cars? What accommodations must be made to increase the business tax base? To comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act?

You work with the mayor's office to figure out how to extract as many freebies from the developer as possible, things like subsidized low-income housing units, wireless Internet for the community, and money for the local schools. You meet with the developer to float the proposal. He's furious and quickly turns the conversation to demanding variances in the building codes and zoning regulations. You knew that was coming.

You get off the phone and weigh the impact of the various proposals on all the people affected. You need to get out of the office, so you visit one of the proposed building sites to mull over the options firsthand. Finally, it's back to your office for a phone call with an economist, who can provide some figures to plug into the first-draft budget you'll start on tomorrow. The official workday ends at 5 p.m., but tonight, you need to lead a public hearing on the project. Everybody has a complaint. Environmentalists warn that wetlands will be destroyed. Preservationists worry that historic buildings might get torn down. Supporters insist that the community desperately needs redevelopment. Your job is simply to present the data. It's up to the politicians to decide whether to build or not.

Smart Specialty

Transportation planner. In light of America ' s desire for energy independence, concern about climate change, and P resident -elect Obama ' s prioritization of mass transit, you might want to make tracks to this specialty.

Private-sector planner. Private-sector planners enjoy more freedom than those in government. Consulting firms hire planners to do things like develop a corporate security plan that's subtle and blends in with the laid-back feel of a building park or corporate campus. Municipalities often hire planning consultants in technical areas like architecture and engineering.

Salary Data

Median (with eight years in the field): $62,500

25th to 75th percentile (with eight or more years of experience): $54,300-$85,600

(Data provided by PayScale.com.)

Training

While half of planners have only a bachelor's degree, as in many fields, degree requirements have been ratcheted up. Today, most entry-level jobs require a master's degree in planning. You'll be additionally marketable if you take courses in structural or civil engineering, economics, architecture, finance, or geographic information systems.

The American Planning Association's offers information on training options.

The Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning publishes a complete list of accredited training programs.

Learn More

Get REAL!!!!!!

As an urban planner with a Master's in City and Regional Planning with a BA in Social Science, emphasis in Sociology & Political Science with a minor in Urban Planning and 13 years of experience I am SHOCKED that this profession is listed anywhere except on a list indicating the stupidest job choice in the WORLD!!!! I've been unemployed since May '09. In October '09 there are only 13 urban planning jobs listed in the entire state of CA on the National APA job site and two of those are for professors! At 44 I'm trying to get a job in anything and I can't even get an interview for a temp agency to do admin or a check-out clerk at the local Safeway!!!! Plus, anything in medical is asking for 2 or more years of experience in MEDICAL. Even if I pay for new training and go into more debt for the education there is no guarantee that I will find work since my fantastic urban planning experience will not transfer.

Therese of CA @ Nov 08, 2009 20:47:26 PM

Planner

Planning as one of the best jobs for 2009--hilarious. The colossal amount of BS you have to put up with, from public agency management and your latest edition of bozo councilpersons, makes for the most inane, soul-numbing career ever. I no longer wonder why veteran public planners all look like they're dead inside; its obvious. And as far as private practice... good luck on staying in business. Maybe when the housing market starts back up you can compete with all the other thousand laid-off planners for those hip positions espousing New Suburbanism (remember that?) or some such garbage.

Planning as a "profession" is a joke. Most planners are either technicians or bureaucrats. The ones who like their job and who encourage others to do it are the planning directors making six figures a year. Unfortunately, only a select few have the ability to claw their way through the local government planning office, waiting 15 years for the next senior planner to retire so they can finally achieve their dream of having their own office and pushing more paper around. Yay. What a career!

All I can say is, kids, DON'T BELIEVE WHAT THEY TELL YOU IN PLANNING SCHOOLS.

Planner of CA @ Nov 06, 2009 18:09:15 PM

Planning in Bangladesh

In Bangladesh planning profession is growing slowly.Day by day it showes its necessity.Being a planner,i hope it will be a demandable profession in bangladesh.But it needs some scopes where planners can play their role perfectly.We are waiting for that days...........

Nusrat Jahan @ Oct 24, 2009 00:06:28 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

U.S. News Rankings & Research

Best Places

Search for the perfect place for you and your family.

Best Careers

Careers that offer strong outlooks and high job satisfaction.

Car Rankings & Reviews

Make an informed choice when shopping for your next car.

advertisement

Slide Shows

The 10 Best Places to Find a Tech Job

IT service jobs—in engineering and in software services—have fared well in this economy.

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!