Take Your Résumé and Shove It

By Liz Wolgemuth

Posted: April 21, 2008

Aaron Strout, vice president of new media at Mzinga

Aaron Strout, vice president of new media at Mzinga

I think anyone who goes down this process has to be respectful of people's privacy...and be flexible in terms of how they are asking people to reach out to them and allow them to sort of look into their private lives.

Does this recruiting process make sense for other industries and jobs?
Absolutely. I pushed the envelope in terms of wanting it to be very social-media focused. I think that you can ask people to go down this path without necessarily pushing the social-media envelope so far. Just: "Show me the blog posts you've done," and—I know that people already do this—do a Google search on someone. If you've spoken at events, include that. So think of it more as an online résumé that has a lot more dimensionality to it.

Some people are getting in trouble for blogs or online profiles that employers don't like. How do people navigate this new gray area?
It's a tricky question, because really it boils down to the company. I guess I would say that people need to be true to themselves, and if you work at a company that you don't feel is a "we" company—an open and honest culture that focuses on conversations and would never fire someone because of something that they wrote in a blog—and you want to be open and honest, you want to be a "we" person, you want to embrace those types of activities, then you need to be looking at working for a company that is true to what's important to you.

Do you see social media changing the job search process for everyone?
I don't see how it can't. Say I'm looking for a salesperson: I'd like to see that they've got 1,000 people on their LinkedIn network, and those are people that might be beneficial to the Rolodex that I'm asking them to come through with.

Taking it a step further and looking at their other social behavior through some of these other tools shows what types of content they read, who they share it with, how they share it. How do they lay out their Facebook page? What types of information flow to the top? Do they strike you as an organized or disorganized person? So a lot of things you'd try to infer from an interview, you can definitely streamline.

That said, I'm not comfortable enough yet to hire someone without sitting with them and feeling that chemistry. It has nothing to do with looks, age, or whatever, but I think that's sort of an old-fashioned gut check that people do. But this helps with the gut check, so it may expedite that, and it may make phone interviews a lot easier in the future.

Do you ever want to look at another résumé again?
You know, once I get far enough down the path, it doesn't hurt to see the résumé. So yes, I do want to see another résumé again. But I want to see it maybe third, fourth, or fifth in the process—not first.

Pros and cons

This approach is great if you're looking for someone in tech, but less so if you're trying to hire a surgeon, for instance.

Also, although you get a much more in-depth look at people, many folks adopt personalities online that may represent only a narrow portion of their totalities, so the picture may be skewed.

Finally, there is still value to Mies van der Rohe's "less is more" as represented bu having to distill your entire life's essence into a single side of an 8 1/2 by 11 inch sheet of paper (my college English professors had to hammer away at me to get me to write LESS in my essays).

So, having buried the lead yet again, I have to summarize by saying, in my usual wishy-washy way, that while online profiles can have great value, the good old résumé is not retiring anytime soon.

Alfonso del Granado of IL @ Jan 31, 2009 12:17:09 PM

Great Article

I keep telling this to everyone, I just dont have the gift of writing to get it out. YOU SAID IT PERFECTLY !!

:)

Maria Ackermann of FL @ Jan 31, 2009 11:52:07 AM

Take Your Résumé and Shove It

Liz,

Take this guy's hiring approach and shove it.

He's just trying to be "different" and show his own boss that he's thinking "outside the box."

The reality is that most 'real' HR departments and hiring managers (who aren't trying to show they're "outside the box.") are still using the old tried and true resume to review and assess people.

Your creativity in putting out a resume that is tasteful, clever, informative and targets the opportunity is how you get the interview. Or at least the phone interview. Clever blogging and social networking only get you so far... then you have to evidence job-specific knowledge and have good interpersonal skills.

This whole blogosphere as job-entry point is BS. Aaron derserves whatever he gets from that approach.

Mike

Mike of NY @ Dec 07, 2008 20:47:12 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

U.S. News Rankings & Research

Best Places

Search for the perfect place for you and your family.

Best Careers

Careers that offer strong outlooks and high job satisfaction.

Car Rankings & Reviews

Make an informed choice when shopping for your next car.

advertisement

Slide Shows

The 10 Best Places to Find a Tech Job

IT service jobs—in engineering and in software services—have fared well in this economy.

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!