The Inside Job

Are We Getting Dumb or Quick?

By Liz Wolgemuth

Posted: June 20, 2008

The half-attentive, ever-antsy nature of our scrolling life on the Web may be making us stupid, the Atlantic Monthly says this month. The story reports on the findings of a University College London study of online research habits: "We may well be in the midst of a sea change in the way we read and think."

The authors of the study report:

It is clear that users are not reading online in the traditional sense; indeed, there are signs that new forms of "reading" are emerging as users "power browse" horizontally through titles, contents pages and abstracts going for quick wins. It almost seems that they go online to avoid reading in the traditional sense.

Now skip on over to Seth Godin's blog and find his notes on the merits and deficiencies of Amazon's electronic Kindle book reader:

The Kindle does a fine job of being a book reader, and a horrible job of actually improving the act of reading a book. This is a surprising design choice, I think, and a mistake. Here are three simple examples of how non-fiction books on the Kindle could be better, not just cheaper and thinner:

  • Let me see the best parts of the book as highlighted by thousands of other readers.
  • Let me see notes in the margin as voted up, Digg-style, by thousands of other readers.
  • Let me interact with hyperlinks and smart connections not just within the book but across books.

One man's regret is another man's recommendation.

When it comes to our jobs and our personal lives, does our Web-wiredness make us quicker and smarter—or does it rob us of nuanced, concentrated thought?

What do we value?

The belated Mortimer Adler presented the idea in "How to Read a Book" that some books should be skimmed,and some read and very few read and read again at more than a 6th grade level. Is it possible that there is a glut of information and very little of it should have more that skimming attributed to it? In our postmodern society, we want it now and many times we just want someone to tell us how to think about something. (ie - I only have time for the sound bite! or Just the facts ma'am). A question is how is that working out for us - society. Does the quickness etc of the computer or e-books, etc. give our lives more quality or more time to do what is truely important (a relative concept - I know)? Is it helping us find the answers we are looking for?

Dixie Zittlow of WI @ Jul 21, 2008 14:34:04 PM

It's About Focus: Counter

Although I worte that multiple foci likely have a negative effect for productivity and intelligence, the need for ideas, vis-a-vis cross pollination, might be enhanced from looking over a broad range of topics or ideas. I'm sure one could argue for the value of less focus...

James of NY @ Jun 23, 2008 10:05:00 AM

It's About Focus

There isn't much to question about bound versus electronic books, but long material requiring engagement versus short internet-based material. Recently, someone described my knowledge as encyclopedic, but I am sometimes jibed by coworkers because I still read bound books, both technical and literature-focused, which I really think is about my age, 48 versus my coworkers, 25 to 35.

My age relates to another fact of internet usage, in that as a boomer, even if the trailing end; my internet use is information driven, not entertainment driven, with a focus on reading abstracts of science and medical articles, as wll as scanning a large range of international news sources. Younger readers might not have the same focus, and are more driven by entertainment or socializing.

As this relates to mental smarts, the internet and computer use can drive people to multitask which is a great time and productivity waster, as well as reducing the intellectual drill-down required to intellectual thought. As a software developer, the need and ability to focus for long periods on single aspects is important, as is the ability to think about systems, and choosing the correct solution. The focus on internet media, as well as the supposed tendency for youth to multitask, seems more harmful than good, at least in terms of smarts, or at least productivity. It's not that something positive can't arise from a reduced multi-target focus...

james Igoe of NY @ Jun 23, 2008 07:59:20 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

The Inside Job

The Inside Job

You're taking a break from your job-hunting and job-hopping ways and have decided to stay put in your current position. Liz Wolgemuth’s careers blog will show you how to make the very best of your job, each day.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!