Is Down Payment Assistance Coming Back?

Back to blog

DAPs are Fraud

Sorry, but I work in the business and I have to agree that the use of seller funded DAPS is fraud. The sales price is kept artificially high by these sorts of transactions, which is bad for everyone. The performance of these no down loans is terrible, many of these people are not creditworthy and get loans that cost them nothing when they walk away (at much higher rates than other loan programs)

al of CA @ Sep 18, 2008 18:48:25 PM

First time home buyer

Unfortunately, my wife and I did not hear about these programs until early September and will not be able to take advantage of these assistance programs when purchasing our first home. I would be ecstatic to hear that Congress extends or even makes these programs permanent. We do not come from wealthy families, but both have great jobs and are working hard to save as much as we can in this tough economy. I say any little assistance would be wonderful!

Eric of SC @ Sep 18, 2008 11:23:16 AM

Pual Howard is clueless

Down payment assistance programs have helped over 1 million creditworthy families become homeowners all without a single taxpayer dollar.

Paul Howard would like you to think that these programs are fraud which they are not. When in fact in 1998 HUD's Office of General Counsel reviewed these programs and approved them to be within FHA regulations. They issued an opinion letter stating as much, which is publicly available.

Paul Howard is concerned about people purchasing their home without any money down. Well, Paul, people have beening buying homes for years without a single dime of their own money...they get it from mommy and daddy. So I guess it is ok for rich peolpe to get their family members into a home without any money but poorer families should not be afforded the same luxury, according to Paul Howard of NJ.

Down payment assistance progarms fund the gifts with contributions from buyers of previous home sales. HUD prohibits sellers from giving buyers a down payment and that is strictly adhered to.

FYI Paul Howard, HUD already tried to change the rule but they were stuck down in not one but two Federal courts who said that these non-profits exist within the letter of the law. And that do indeed help people become homeowners and HUD's rationale was completely baseless. Oh, BTW, Congress does have something to say about it. They are working on keeping these valuable programs.

John Stanley of MD @ Sep 18, 2008 11:08:56 AM

Seller funded

Many of us who opposed the program as it existed did so because it was a fraud. The program allowed gifts from non profits to buyers. Fine.

FHA has a restriction that a seller can't contribute more then an amount equal to 6 percent of the purchase price toward a seller's closing costs and can't contribute at all toward down payment.

The gifts from non profits were outside of this limit allowing a buyer to buy a house with no money of his own at all.

But where did the so called 'nonprofit' get the money to give? From the same seller that would not have been allowed to give it directly.

In some cases the participants were required to sign a document stating that the money the buyer received from the 'nonprofit' was not the same money that the seller gave to the 'non profit'.

Of course, it was the same money except that the 'nonprofit' kept a percentage for it's trouble in transferring the money. A few hundred dollars worth of trouble. If HUD wants to allow the additional seller assist (above the 6 percent already allowed) ...they don't need a third party (the nonprofit) with their hand in the till to accomplish it. All they have to do is change the rule. Of course congress might have something to say about that too.

Paul Howard of NJ @ Sep 17, 2008 22:50:04 PM

Back to blog

Add Your Thoughts
About You
The Home Front

The Home Front

Associate Editor Luke Mullins tracks the treacherous housing market and explains how to unload a five-bedroom McMansion or even find that dream home.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!