Risky Business

On That Rick Santelli 'Rant Of The Year': What's The Multiplier For Government Spending?

By Matthew Bandyk

Posted: February 20, 2009

Rick Santelli's CNBC rant is getting a lot of attention for its passionate delivery. But is there any substance to it that would actually change anybody's mind?

Take his sarcastic comments about the stimulus package.

He said:

They are pretty much of the notion you can't buy your way into prosperity. If the multiplier that all of these Washington economists are selling us is over 1, then we never have to worry about the economy again! The government should spend a trillion dollars an hour, that way we'll get 1.5 back!

So it's simply on-face ridiculous that government spending will yield back returns? If only it were that easy to just say that and be done with it!

If you look at some of the actual spending in the stimulus package, the argument that we're just shuffling money around--and not making real investments--becomes a bit more persuasive. Check out my piece at Yahoo! Finance on the projects in the bill that may or may not be considered pork barrel spending.

But to be fair, as I note, no matter your definition of "pork," it still makes up a minority of the stimulus.

I agree with Rick Santelli

Matt,

Try selling this somewhere else. Too many of us have seen the bologna that is in this "stimulus" package. If you want to create jobs - offer a tax credit to companies for each job they create. If you want to save the stock market - eliminate capital gains tax - which is a way to tax my money twice anyway. If you want to stimulate the housing market - offer a tax credit to EVERY home buyer and not just first time buyers (many of which will be high risk debt I expect). I have no issue with bailing out banks as long as we stop the foolish programs to encourage poor people to borrow money they can’t pay back. In the end, I bet all of these things could be accomplished for a fraction of the cost of the stimulus package. The LAST thing we need is expanded social programs we will never be able to cut back. Economics is all about incentive. We need to incentivize the right behaviors. The Obama plan incentivizes dependency and foolish borrowing. And how about that Octo Mom. Somehow she can afford two in-vitro procedures, plastic surgery to look like Angelina Jolie - but I need to pay for her rent and food.... Only in America. And here is another way to rescue the economy – stop providing health, education, and social welfare benefits to illegal aliens! Enough is enough…. The bottom line is that the things Obama is implementing are morally wrong. Stealing from some to subsidize others, ramming pork and paybacks through as stimulus, and the media acting as Obama's defensive team - blocking all would be tacklers. Shame on the mainstream media. You have no integrity.

JT

JT of TX @ Feb 23, 2009 00:26:41 AM

Stimulous v Pork

PORK is spending a trillion dollars on an unnessary war- that has killed or maimed tens of thousands. Worst part is Bush & McCain voted no many times on increased funding to Vets. Thats a fact.Trying to jump start the economy with a stimulous - that's not pork. Folks, Its been all of 35 days..lets give Obama a fair shake, to see what he can do- at least 18-24 months. This crisis developed over 25 + years- since Reagan's policy of deregulation. Obama won 12 states that had not gone Democratic in 25-30 years. That's a very strong message. It says we've had enough of GOP policies that led us to disaster. The GOP wants power back so bad, they'll do anything to crush Obama.

Dianrib of IL @ Feb 22, 2009 17:34:01 PM

Santelli's rant & Reagan / Bush policies of deregulation !

Yes, Rick's rant has truth to it. HOWEVER- I'm waiting for Wall Street types to admit that the Reagan / Bush policies of deregulation that gave " Free reign ' to greed on Wall St & Bankers-they did as they damn well pleased. That's what caused this huge crisis. Add trickle down economics and 2 huge tax cuts (Reagan and Bush) No one gives huge tax cuts while fighting 2 wars- .except W.

Bush,Cheney,Reagan & Wall Street really bleeped the country good. Hope they all sleep well at night. Along with the Madoff's of the world.

Dianrib of IL @ Feb 22, 2009 17:21:09 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Risky Business

Risky Business

Matt Bandyk, a reporter for U.S. News, explores capitalism from where it all begins, with the entrepreneur, whose risk taking and experimentation provide the roots from which the rest of the economy grows. As much courage as it takes to create one's own business, even the entrepreneur needs some help, and this blog will look at news, trends, and practical advice for starting and running a small business.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!