Risky Business

Don't Let "Green Jobs" Be Obama's Patriot Act

By Matthew Bandyk

Posted: December 24, 2008

My worry with Obama's planned environmentally-friendly infrastructure projects has been that it will another case of failed industrial policy: the government trying to artificially prop up programs that are not viable in the market, instead of helping entrepreneurs produce what is efficient.

Today's Washington Post story on the internal debate going on about the stimulus bill makes me more concerned:

But the green-collar proposals have also come under fire. Hill, the incoming Blue Dog co-chairman, said he opposes including these proposals and the medical technology project in the stimulus plan, suggesting that "somewhere down the road" they be considered under the normal legislative process.

How can we properly debate whether or not these spending projects are "green" boondoggles if they are buried in a bill that will be probably be hundreds of pages long?

I bring up the Patriot Act not to suggest that Obama is trying to take away our civil liberties through his stimulus spending. Instead, we should look to the Patriot Act as an example of when some proposals were snuck into a much larger bill, and then created costs down the road because they were not given enough consideration. Let's have the "green-collar" debate be fully transparent. That can't happen if the policies are hidden in a massive stimulus bill that will be rushed through Congress.

Sigh

How many times do we have to have examples of technology that starts out "not efficient" and no "entrepreneur" would (or could) touch it that ends up becoming cheap and pervasive before people like you shut up?

Not to mention, you DO know who built the Internet yes? We call them "The United States Federal Government". Heard of them? It was not until after they poured money into a system nobody else would build that we ended up with a pervasive system that enables you types to yap about how government can't do anything right.

There are now two green technologies that are nearing competitive pricing with coal. And, yes, solar *IS* one of them (does anybody read anymore, every "discussion" I see about solar is like reading the papers from the 70s, nobody is up on what's been going on these last three decades or so).

Every technology from cell phones to CDs to DVDs has started out expensive and available only to the wealthy. Until they hit mass production. Now they're cheap enough to be impulse buys for the kids. What's needed is an infusion of money to get us to mass production. Get it?

Such as thin film solar (look it up). If I had my way, the USG would start buying it by the truckloads and *giving it away*. Projections of the cost of thin film once it hits mass production put it competitive, if not whipping the pants off of, coal.

I am *so* tired of hearing about "entreepeenoors". The bulk of that is mere corporate propaganda. Very, very, VERY few things are created by the guy in his garage. And most of the time when that does happen, a corporation steals it (ask the guy who invented the easy change socket wrench only to have to sue Sears for THIRTEEN YEARS to get his patent honored.

Not to mention, I personally knew a guy who invented something that's on your telephone right now and millions of telephones worldwide and he went bankrupt.

And don't even start to say "Gates". His mommy was an IBM exec. If he did anything in the garage, it was yell at the guy who polished his Beemer.

Anyway.

If government infusion and support for basic infrastructure doesn't work, I say there's no Internet and you're having an hallucination. There also is no Amazon, no Google, no Yahoo, no Internet commerce, and no Internet millionaires.

Okay, so maybe there are (I don't know, I haven't read it) things in the Obama plan that will flop. Not everything works. And giving things to "entreepeenoors" isn't some kind of magic that'll make things that don't work suddenly work.

Funny how you "government doesn't work" types never question the government having nuclear weapons. If "duh goverment" is so incompetent, shouldn't you be worried about them having bombs that could obliterate whole countries?

Mark of TX @ Mar 07, 2009 10:14:38 AM

Green Jobs

I don't think we should be burying anything in any of the bills in Congress. Passing "projects" which are buried in legislation is irresponsible government and should be stopped.

CJ of IN @ Jan 01, 2009 14:33:21 PM

Re: Ancient Cherokee Wisdom

Ron Paul

Jeff of WI @ Dec 26, 2008 08:06:05 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Risky Business

Risky Business

Matt Bandyk, a reporter for U.S. News, explores capitalism from where it all begins, with the entrepreneur, whose risk taking and experimentation provide the roots from which the rest of the economy grows. As much courage as it takes to create one's own business, even the entrepreneur needs some help, and this blog will look at news, trends, and practical advice for starting and running a small business.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!