Planning to Retire

Who Is Targeting Your 401(k)?

By Emily Brandon

Posted: November 19, 2008

A Wall Street Journal editorial published Friday suggests that congressional Democrats have plans to eliminate 401(k) tax breaks and are "entertaining dreams of state-managed retirement accounts."

Rep. George Miller, the California Democrat who chairs of the House Education and Labor Committee, shot back with a statement the same day. "The Wall Street Journal is needlessly creating fear among Americans rightly worried about their retirement security by misrepresenting my efforts to strengthen workers' retirement savings—attacks that have no basis in fact. I do not support 'abolishing' 401(k)'s, moving these plans, or changing their tax status, plain and simple," Miller said.

Miller stated that his goals for 401(k)'s are to expose excess fees, bring more young and low-wage workers into the system through automatic enrollment, promote inexpensive and diversified investment options, encourage independent and objective investment advice, and reduce vesting periods to make 401(k)'s more portable.

MSNBC says the 401(k) congressional hearings in October have reached urban-legend status and published a debunker piece about the ensuing Internet controversy.

Tell us, what 401(k) issues would you like to see Congress address?

The problem I have with social security and pension plans is that I am not in control of my future. In both cases someone else is making the decisions and I have to live with the mess they create, because they will serve their interest first and my interest second. At least with a plan like a 401K or an IRA me and the the person managing it have an understanding. I want to have a good retirement and it is in their best interest to provide it, because if they do not I will take my business and money elsewhere.

The problem we have now in the market was created by the Congress on both side manipulating it in their best interest, not mine. If I had actually known what was going on, I would of made changes in how I was investing sooner. I had an inkling that things were going to fall, but did not have the details and could not point to anything specific. I have know started looking for additional sources so that I do not get caught unaware again.

Freddy Boisseau of VA @ Nov 30, 2008 07:13:01 AM

401K PROBLEMS

I'd like to see Congress redress the inequity of insuring company pensions,but not the one I've funded myself. This is all messed up. Basically, as a taxpayer I get to pay for state, local and federal employee pensions, for bankrupt companies' obligations---when do I get to address my own needs?

Marieelna of NY @ Nov 28, 2008 19:39:55 PM

401k

I'd love to see us stop subsidizing wall street. They're getting free money and look what they've done with it since 401k's started -they blew it.

none of IA @ Nov 22, 2008 22:30:58 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Planning to Retire

Planning to Retire

Reporter Emily Brandon tells you how to get ready financially for retirement and to make your golden years the best they can be.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!