New Money

Spore Spawns Virtual Protest

By Katy Marquardt

Posted: September 10, 2008

Electronic Arts has had a tough week. Shares of the largest video game publisher began declining Monday after the company announced a delay in the release of its highly anticipated Harry Potter video game (it had been scheduled for release in time for the holiday shopping season). Meanwhile, some Wall Streeters speculated that the release of three other titles—including Spore—could boost the company's ailing stock (symbol ERTS). It closed at $44 yesterday, near the 52-week low of $41.17.

Although Spore has been well received by critics, the game's restrictive digital rights management software—which limits players to just three installations—has sparked outrage among some gamers.

Of the 1,963 customer reviews of Spore on Amazon.com, the game has received 1,812 one-star reviews. These include "Dumbed down experience and draconian DRM," and "DRM makes me a sad panda."

Wired weighs in:

Their goal, it seems, is to influence those Amazon.com patrons who rely solely on the site's reviews to make purchasing decisions. If they can sink that sales avenue, the corporations responsible for the DRM will be forced to change their ways, they seem to believe.

EA says the practice is an industry standard, citing Apple's policy of allowing downloaded music to be played on only three devices, reports the Financial Times.

But not everyone in the industry agrees. Late last month, Stardock, maker of the critically acclaimed Sins of a Solar Empire computer game (which has no copy protection), published a "Gamers Bill of Rights," which included "gamers shall have the right to redownload the latest version of the games they own at any time," and "gamers ... shall not be treated as potential criminals by developers or publishers."

EA is just not on..

mann, most annoying crap to date for paying people. its allmost better to get a console for games, cause pc its jsut retarted with allthe protection on paying people, CD-key are fine and all but limted it just not on...

almost temped to use hacks to get past the install and then use my account to log in!! (not that HAVEING to be loged in ONLINE to play a OFFLINE game but it beats haveing limted installs

Fates @ Oct 05, 2008 07:15:26 AM

EA's DRM is a Rootkit

That Spore will only install three times is a minor point when you consider what it is SecuROM is doing. It installs secretly, uses malware tricks to prevent it's removal, and creates files and folders that you can not see and can not remove. It accesses priviledged system-level commands and generally behaves like a virus.

of MD @ Sep 11, 2008 12:40:08 PM

Slanted Reporting

Virtual protest? Trying to sink Spore's sales to force a change in EA's policy? Sez who?

I gave a negative review to a product I purchased from Amazon -- as did 2000 other people, for more or less the same reason. The reason is that Spore has a hidden companion -- Securom -- which not only can interfere with other installed programs but can also cause hardware failure. Worse, IT CANNOT BE UNINSTALLED. Uninstalling Spore will not uninstall Securom, which can only be removed by reinstalling Windows or directly editing its registries and services.

Calling a negative review of a product a "protest" suggests that the review is not a real product review designed to inform other consumers and demeans it. Other coverage of the negative reviews on Spore have referred to "flash mobs" and "petulant children." Sorry -- I'm a 45 year old professional who doesn't want to trash my computer with malware. How unreasonable is that?

A 45 Year Old Gamer of MD @ Sep 11, 2008 05:58:36 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

New Money

Katy Marquardt, a senior editor at U.S.News & World Report, takes a contemporary look at happenings in the financial world and aims to help young investors get going with their portfolios--or just sound cool at cocktail parties. Have a question? E-mail Katy at newmoney@usnews.com

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!