Luxe Life

YouTube Symphony Orchestra Performs at Carnegie Hall

By Kimberly Castro

Posted: April 16, 2009

The world's first collaborative online orchestra debuted at Carnegie Hall last night. The YouTube Symphony Orchestra, selected by the YouTube community and members of the most celebrated orchestras, is made up of 93 musicians, ages 15 to 55, from more than 30 countries.

Michael Tilson Thomas, Grammy-winning music director and the evening's conductor, likened the experience to a melding of real-time and online worlds. "For us, it's been somewhere between a kind of classical music/summit conference/scout jamboree with an element of speed dating thrown in," he told the audience in his introduction. "Actually, over the last nine months, so many people from many different countries with different talents, priorities, perspectives have contributed to the form and content of this evening...It's all about these terms that we hear—terms of the Internet—like "interactive," "creative," "fluid," "democratic,"—these things have nothing to do with the normal world of maestromdom."

The musicians, who met for the first time in New York on Sunday, played a wide range of works from Gabrieli, Brahms, Dvorak, Bach, Mozart, Tchaikovsky, and John Cage. The performance also included the premiere of contemporary Chinese composer Tan Dun's "Internet Symphony No. 1, Eroica."

Thousands of videos were submitted by amateur and professional musicians from around the world. The online community voted for their favorite instrumentalists on YouTube in mid-February. The submissions were compiled into a mashup video, which premiered on YouTube on April 15th.

Last month, British magazine Gramophone named the YTSO as one of the world's 10 most inspiring orchestras "for democratizing classical music on a global scale, making it truly all-inclusive." Last night, the orchestra received a standing ovation from a sold-out audience.

Concert success

The video speaks for itself, perhaps, but I was delighted to attend the debut concert of the You Tube Symphony Wednesday night in person. The sound was fabulous. Hard to believe that the ninety-some performers had never played together until less than a week before.

I would like to compliment the woodwinds, who played with marvelous clarity, but the brass section was also fantastic. I I would have gladly heard ten more Gabrieli "echo" pieces such as the one performed from the opposing balconies. Likewise, the string sections sang as one virtuoso instrument.

The percussionists clearly knew their stuff as well. However, I would have been happier without the John Cage piece. That's not the fault of the performers, but of the pretentious yet nonsensical composition.

I have to hope that the next performance of the You Tube Symphony Orchestra will break out of the Cage.

The vocal soloist, Ms. Brueggersgosmann, obviously has immense ability, but her talent was wasted on meaningless jabber.

On the positive side, the short videos highlighting certain members of the orchestra added a welcome human interest dimension. And the flying fingers of Yuja Wang were nothing short of phenomenal.

Barry Wood of VA @ Apr 17, 2009 16:43:34 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Luxe Life

Luxury is no longer the sole province of the elite. Upscale goods and services now target a much broader market. Kimberly Castro, deputy business editor of U.S.News & World Report, takes a look at the luxe life, from fine wines and cars to high-end real estate and wealth management. Though no elitist, Kim does admit a fondness for a bold bottle of Scout's Honor from Venge Vineyards and satiating her wanderlust in Europe.

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!