Fresh Greens

Would You Play in a Park that Used to Be a Landfill?

By Maura Judkis

Posted: December 3, 2008

New York Magazine takes a detailed look at the former Fresh Kills Landfill, and James Corner, the architect who is working to reclaim it. The heaps of trash that were built up on the Staten Island dump from 1948 until 2001 comprise one of the world's largest manmade structures. Though the dump has been closed ever since (with the exception of some loads of post-9/11 debris), parts of Fresh Kills will reopen within the next two years - as an outdoor oasis three times the size of Central Park.

Which begs the question - how would you feel about playing tennis, hiking and even kayaking through a site that used to be heaped to the height of the Statue of Liberty with trash? Most of has been buried, of course. An article on Scienceline about the project says that the mounds of trash are enclosed in plastic or clay, and then covered with two feet of clean soil, which now sprouts with wild grasses. Pipes allow methane gas, sold as fuel, to escape from the decomposing heaps as they compress. Leachate, a mix of water and chemical garbage sludge, channels out from underneath the mounds, and is processed like sewage.

Corner's design doesn't gloss over the site's past. The methane pipes, which hiss audibly with the sound of escaping gas, will remain, and be vandal-proofed. There will be a memorial to the victims of the World Trade Center collapse, because many of their remains were mixed in the building debris that is now underfoot. The trash heaps, which led New York Magazine to dub the site "Wall-E Park," are the central part of Corner's plan for the site:

"I was just blown away by the scope and beauty of the place," he recalls. Embracing the hills was as counterintuitive to most city-park design as it was consistent with Corner's philosophy of landscape, which was to take chances with what he called "the tough, machinic, strange quality of these sites" to reinvent a city dweller's recreational landscape. The takeaway point: Keep the views, which he knew would blow away every New Yorker who will, 40 years from now, take a hybrid bus or solar-powered ferry to the place. "I said, 'Look, whatever we do we've got to keep the big and green. These are views and vistas that most people in a city would have to drive three or four hours to see.'"

According to Michael Marrella, a project administrator from the Department of City Planning, "the infrastructure to keep the landfill gas and juices flowing will be less of a danger to people than they will be to it." Photos that go with the article promise spectacular vistas, and a genuinely beautiful space.

 

So, would you bike and picnic in the park atop the trash?
I trust the engineers. They will design a park that is safe, and it will be great for New Yorkers.
Well, maybe I wouldn’t go swimming there.
Sure, great idea. I’ll send my kids to tennis lessons there after they’re done with baseball practice on Three Mile Island.
I don't even leave my own house without hand sanitizer, so even if the trash is buried and covered with flowers, the answer is no.


View results without voting

 

Requires JavaScript

capped landfulls

I have no problem and I was reading w/ your Chem/Physics background if you might have any info about a local landfill. The case is that our HOH (wells) is all very hard and sulfur like in odor. Now about 2 miles away we have a BFI landfill that was capped/closed because it supposedly did not have a proper shell beneath it. I often wonder if our water situation is from the sludge leaching out of the landfill there somewhere like a 3 mile line from my house. Others say that our wells are like this b/c this area used to be saturated w/ coal mines and it's the water that has backfilled into the mines and is leaching back out into the water table. The landfill was a BFI landfill in Deerfield, Ohio if that is of any help.

Heather of OH @ Dec 09, 2008 23:00:37 PM

A landfill can become a garden, so why not a park

Hi,

I just found your blog via the Huffington Post and read this article.

I wouldn't mind going into such a park after having visited in France a beautiful garden that once was a landfill.

Keep up the good work !

Edouard Stenger, France @ Dec 05, 2008 11:59:06 AM

Yep

Thanks Ali, for reminding me to mention - this is not the first park made out of a landfill, by any means. I it will be the largest, though, and will serve a much larger population than the rest of the landfill-turned-parks.

Maura Judkis of DC @ Dec 04, 2008 11:01:53 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Fresh Greens

Fresh Greens

Maura Judkis is a producer at U.S. News. She writes about the green movement and looks for ways to be an ecofriendly consumer without breaking the bank. Send her your green tips.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!