Rick Newman

11 Places With a Worse Economy Than Ours

By Rick Newman

Posted: July 10, 2009

When times are tough, one thing that tends to raise the spirits is knowing that somebody else has it worse. And as wretched as the U.S. economy seems, it's not as bad as in other regions.

The International Monetary Fund's latest tally of world economic conditions forecasts a 2.6 decline in U.S. economic output for all of 2009, and anemic growth of 0.8 percent in 2010. That's more optimistic than the IMF's prediction from three months ago, but those are still lousy numbers. A weak economy throughout 2010 would mean a bleak employment picture, an agonizingly slow housing recovery, and another year or two likely to feel like a recession, whether it's technically labeled that or not.

[See what Obama must do before Stimulus II.]

We should count ourselves lucky, though. The IMF expects at least 11 major parts of the world to have more severe economic contractions than the United State this year, including most of western Europe, Japan, Russia, and Mexico. Europe will still be stumbling along behind the United States next year, as well. Here are the IMF's projections for economic growth in various parts of the world:

  2009 2010
China 7.5 8.5
India 5.4 6.5
Middle East 2.0 3.7
Africa 1.8 4.7
Brazil -1.3 2.5
World total -1.4 2.5
Canada -2.3 1.6
U.S. -2.6 0.8
France -3.0 0.4
Spain -4.0 -0.8
U.K. -4.2 0.2
European Union -4.7 -0.1
Central/Eastern Europe -5.0 1.0
Italy -5.1 -0.1
Japan -6.0 1.7
Germany -6.2 -0.6
Russia -6.5 1.5
Mexico -7.3 3.0

 

If these projections come true, it means the United States, despite its overspent consumers, wrecked banks, and insolvent automakers, will be leading the world economy out of recession. Somehow. The developing world will help, but those high growth projections in China and India can be deceiving. China in particular has government policies that practically mandate high growth, and 8.5 percent in 2010 would be just about the bare minimum to keep employment at tolerable levels. And neither China nor India is a major buyer of American-made goods and services; for the most part, it's the other way around. With much of the developed world trailing the United States, it will take American consumers to ratchet up demand for the world's products. Scary thought.

[See how to tell when a real recovery begins.]

The IMF does offer a bit of more heartening news: The global wipeout finally seems to be receding. "The world economy is stabilizing," the IMF reports. Its global economic growth projection of 2.5 percent in 2010 is 0.6 points higher than predicted in April. But the global economy isn't expected to gain its footing in earnest until the second half of 2010. Maybe by then American spenders will have come out of hiding.

William telling the truth!!!

I am absolutely agree. Global domnination it is a moron idea. Why we should spend our tax to builds military bases on Germany, Italy, & Japan.

Jamie of MA @ Sep 09, 2009 18:33:16 PM

HI

In my opinion we get out of these if Banks and Feds are not friends togather.

The Banking system is very corrupt and Fed hires oild frindes and they are the real crooks.

Our leaders in Govt. are greedy and corrupt and they make laws for American to see that all that they are doing good for Ameicans but there is diffrent agenda and law to benefit them sleves.

All these people need to be out Washington and new age from new blood shall begain.

Our leaders are putting our great nation at greater rick then we all think.

Vj of TX @ Jul 28, 2009 22:06:17 PM

How to fix Americas economy

We need to start making products that other contries need and can afford. I feel we spend entirely too much money on Defense. In 1961 President Eisenhowser tried to warn us of the hidden dangers of the Military Industrieal Complex. He roughly stated that if we don't control it it could bring us down as a nation. WW2 has been over for 60 years. Do we really need to keep so many military bases in Germany, Italy, & Japan? I am a veteran and have personally witnessed the waste the military produces and personally it makes me very angry. Some people in many places of the world do not buy American products due to thier unhappiness of U.S. policies. Others buy Toyota or Hyandia due to price. If we closed down just 50% of our bases in Japan and Korea our government could lower taxes. If they lowered taxes the workers in ther UAW could work for less money and then the cost of american cars might be on par with the Koreans or Japanese. You can blame the current crises on the banks and greedy corporations, but I feel no one has addressed the real problem. I feel the real problem is that America cannot compete with other countries. People who do not have jobs cannot pay their debts to banks. Many don't have jobs because they have been sent to other countries such as Korea or Mexico( where people work for much less). We need to re-asses our priorities. If we want to be more competitive in the global economy we need to stop wasting money on wars and military global domination. If we were to close half of our overseas bases and put the troops on U.S. soil the money would stay in U.S. communities. I feel that we should let the Koreans pay for thier own defence. Lets see if they can import a fully loaded luxury car for half the price if they had to pay for their own defence. In essence we are subsidizing our own competitors, how stupid is that? Are we such fools. Whith the money saved from overseas base closures we could then liquidate our foriegn debts. Again with less costs we could lower taxes and wages. Then America can start pruducing goods for export, at prices poeple in Asia or Africa could afford.

I aslo believe the time is right for world communities to discuss the concept of a universal wage and work standards. For example by avereging severeral world currencies we could estimate a fair labor wage. Sadly in many countries such as China and Mexico the workers can't stand up to currupt governments and demand fair saleries. In order order to fix the world economy we need to spur consumption. Does anyone really think its fair for a worker in Chine to work long hours for pennies? I am sure if multinational companies were forced into paying workers fair wages, they would not be sending all our jobs to China and Mexico. One of the major causes of the great depression was under consumption. If a worker in a Mexican Mequiladora factory is paid $4,000 U.S. annually do you think he or she can buy an American made computor or Car ? Whare's the Justice?

William J. Mueller @ Jul 28, 2009 17:45:00 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Rick Newman

Rick Newman

The global economy is mysterious, even scary. Chief Business Correspondent Rick Newman connects the dots. In addition to his writing for U.S. News, Rick is the co-author of two books: Firefight: Inside the Battle to Save the Pentagon on 9/11, and Bury Us Upside Down: The Misty Pilots and the Secret Battle for the Ho Chi Minh Trail.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!