Rick Newman

Cars Hurt Most by $4 Gas

By Rick Newman

Posted: June 10, 2008

Call it the revenge of the little guys. With gas prices officially cresting $4—and running higher in many parts of the country—American drivers are finally downsizing in big numbers. Overall auto sales are down about 8 percent so far this year—but sales of large cars and trucks have plunged 23 percent, according to J.D. Power & Associates. There's no mystery behind the shift: Buyers clearly believe high gas prices are here to stay, and are desperate to cut their gas bills.

Among the cars piling up on dealer lots, here are some of the biggest losers:

Hummer. Sierra Clubers can go ahead and cheer: Hummer sales are down by 36 percent so far this year, the biggest drop among a single brand. Sales of the smallest Hummer—the H3, which averages about 15 mpg—have fallen even more than the brawnier H2, which gets a meager 10 mpg or so. Consider some painful Hummer math: With gas at $4, it costs about $120 to fill the tank of an H2, and then you can only go about 300 miles before forking over another $120. No wonder General Motors is considering offloading the whole division.

Nissan Titan. This pickup has never caught on like its American counterparts, and sales are off 45 percent for the year. But even the venerable American brands are hurting. Dodge Ram sales are off 27 percent; Chevy Silverado sales, 26 percent. Sales of the Ford F series, down a mere 19 percent, look healthy by comparison.

Jeep Commander. That thing got a Hemi? Better hope not. The big V-8 engine was a hit back when gas was $1.50, but sales of the Commander—city mileage with the optional Hemi: 13 mpg—have plummeted 48 percent so far this year. Other SUVs are in bad shape, too. Sales of virtually every midsize SUV have fallen by double digits, and there's now such a glut that some dealers won't even accept an SUV as a trade-in.

Chrysler. That deal to lock in $2.99 gas was supposed to move some metal in a tough market, yet Chrysler sales are down 19 percent for the year—with a 25 percent drop in May, when the $2.99 deal was supposed to be luring buyers. The hulking Chrysler 300, a huge hit that supposedly redefined American muscle when it debuted in 2004, now looks as passé as tail fins: Sales are down 31 percent.

Saturn. General Motors has revitalized this division's entire lineup, with enticing new right-size vehicles like the Outlook and Vue crossovers and the Aura sedan. But buyers aren't, well, buying it. Sales are down 20 percent.

Toyota Avalon. Yes, even Toyota is struggling in segments, and while the Avalon sedan is more spacious than the popular Camry, there's only one engine choice, a six-cylinder. That's one reason sales are off 33 percent, a lot more than slightly smaller sedans that come with a four-cylinder option. Sales of every other large four-door are down, too, as the family sedan shrinks. It was nice while it lasted.

Best thing to DO..its easy

Get your self a cheap 4 cylinder and keep good maintenance care of it and it will do great things for you! Simple as that! Hybrids are nice but too pricey! Big cars are nice too, but they are pricey plus they hurt on the gas part, so overall just stick with a cheap four cylinder. Unless you want to buy a hybrid which will cost so much more and since they're suppose to save gas they have less power. Who wants to drive a car that can't climb a hill??? My girlfriend owns a prius. No doubt it saves a lot of gas but it is so weak!!! Have fun rolling backwards on the road when you try to climb a hill. Another thing people try to buy cars that take 87 gas. Luxury is nice, but paying for premium gas....just to drive like any other car its kind of stupid...be smart people!!

Preston Tanner of AR @ Nov 14, 2008 11:08:31 AM

Good to Hear

It's good to hear that people give a carp.

It's absurd to blame the lazy union worker who just wants a better lot for the short-sightedness of our Big (stupid, selfish) 3. That is like blaming the toddler that gets to eat his desert first because he cries. Time to Pay the Piper. The Big 3 have constantly fought higher CAFE standards, they said to adopt them would put them out of business. Well GM is going out of business, so get used to it. They have a failed long term vision, like the rebellious toddler. I give them less than 18 months before they start threatening our government with their financial problems, looking for handouts. They obviously don't have the vision it takes to move forward, they have been listening to their own lies so long.

But as goes GM, so goes the US......

So yeah, our consumer debt has doubled, our government debt has doubled, but we are very creative and resilient and we could make it through, if only we could let go of that saying that we should have let go of 30 years ago. Say goodbye to GM and their stubborn mentality. Lets find someone with a "new" vision like Quantum, or someone that cares about potential and efficiency, take us into the renewable age.

As for those who have to drive SUVs, we celebrate choice, and to stay in business, of course, you have to pass on your costs. I think we all realize that. Drive on...

And Kudos to the Natural Gas advocate, Hydrogen or Bust!

But don't be so hard on the Canadian. If our country were to have put a 40% tax on fuel (and spent the proceeds on pushing our slumbering companies into the next era) we wouldn't be in this mess (excuse me, these messes). We wouldn't have a business failure as a president, we wouldn't be invading sovereign countries, we wouldn't have so many fat**ses sitting on the couch eating tv dinners while they watch our economy get outstripped by the likes of Romania and our technology get superseded by the Danes. Our gov't is willing to put a protective tariff on steel (17% - ?fact check?), a health and safety tax on our cigarettes, but really, only 10% on the most wasteful and most harmful commodity of our time!! Completely ridiculous were the claims - "consumers will never pay it", "we'll go out of business if you do that" never mind that railroads are more efficient, or private companies were willing to pay for half the cost of a high speed train, we must allow Exxon and GM to lead us into the new era of doom and gloom. And even now, Exxon considers their tax breaks crucial to their R&D that will lead us away from this armageddon. Exxon is the biggest joke (after The administration) and unfortunately, unlike GM, Exxon has enough money to suppress science and new inventions for years to come, and will in all likelihood morph into the next era as an energy company, not a oil company.

It's not too late to treat Exxon like Philip Morris, but first we must just say "goodbye" to GM, it was a good time, but it is time for you to go.

kv of FL @ Jul 01, 2008 19:43:02 PM

MPG or Safety

I will drive my GMC Yukon with its 12mpg even if gas hits $8 a gallon as long as

I live in California. After being the vicitim of 3 car wrecks in the last 12 years I

only had minor injuries in 2 of them thanks to driving a big car and SUV. Next time some irresponsible moron decides to crash into me with thier little economy

car they will be the one that ends up in the hospital or crushed to death. Gas

prices are still a bargain compared to the high cost of medical and losing work

due to car crash injuries. I can giveup the weekend ride in the country and the

drive across town to save $10 on a sale. It is cheaper to drive a 10 year old gas

guzzling SUV that is paid for than to drive a new econocar with $500 a month

payments, high insurance and registration fees.

Billy of CA @ Jun 28, 2008 14:23:38 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Rick Newman

Rick Newman

The global economy is mysterious, even scary. Chief Business Correspondent Rick Newman connects the dots. In addition to his writing for U.S. News, Rick is the co-author of two books: Firefight: Inside the Battle to Save the Pentagon on 9/11, and Bury Us Upside Down: The Misty Pilots and the Secret Battle for the Ho Chi Minh Trail.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!