Dave's Download

Seagate Replica Makes for Easy PC Backup

By David LaGesse

Posted: April 27, 2009

The $200 version has a dock

The $200 version has a dock

Just a click of the mouse is all it takes to back up a PC to the Seagate Replica, a new external model from the hard drive maker. Seagate thus joins a number of other companies in trying to radically simplify back ups. They're trying to stir us from our dangerous lethargy of computing without a safety net.

Just plug the Replica into the USB port on a PC and it automatically loads its own software. The ever-cautious Seagate requires you to click once on a license agreement, and then the software quietly does its thing in the background. It backs up the PC's main hard drive, and updates the backup as files change.

That's one more click than other products, notably Clickfree. I've found Clickfree and a similar online service from Backblaze to be among the simplest backup products out there. The Replica is basically as simple, and more comprehensive.

Where Clickfree and Backblaze only protect data, such as music files and digital photos, Replica, er, replicates the entire main hard drive of a PC. That would enable a computer user to recover from a crash of the operating system. At least in theory. I didn't take time to restore an entire system.

The drive appears to work as advertised. But I did run into an unexpected bump. The Replica wouldn't even install its software when I plugged it into a PC that had a 1TB main drive. Replica told me "There is not enough space to protect your PC" in a box that looked like a Windows error message.

In fact, there wasn't enough space because the drive was only 500 GB. But the message was rather abrupt and unhelpful for what is otherwise well-crafted software that accompanies the Replica.

On other PCs, the Replica worked smoothly. It's also attractive in a slim, rounded case, and sells for a reasonable $200 for 500 GB ($130 for 250 GB). It won't work with Macs, or even some older PCs (it requires drives formatted in the NTFS file system).

Restore could be a problem

Dave,

The image backup that Replica does can only be restored to a computer that is "identical in every way” to the one backed up. In other words, I can't move this information to another computer or if the worst happens and some piece of hardware fails (mboard, hdd), it will not work, as it is no longer identical.

My concern with Backblaze is safety and security given what happened to Carbonite a few months ago. If safety AND security are a concern about a backup plan, then it doesn't seem to be much of a plan.

Clickfree seems to be a good choice because of it's ease of use and flexibility. I read your reviews on the DVD and transformer products. Will you do a review on any of their other products? I'm close to a purchase.

Samuel of CA @ May 28, 2009 16:14:39 PM

Looks good

Given my recent failed experiments with the HP MediaSmart Server, I'm thinking this might make a fine standalone solution to protect Melissa's laptop - which is both her business and personal computing device. Her drive is 320GB, though it's probably only 20% full at this point - wonder if the 250GB Replica drive would be happy with it? Hm.

DaveZatz of MD @ Apr 28, 2009 08:05:30 AM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Dave's Download

Our in-house gadget guru, Senior Writer David LaGesse, checks out the latest technologies and gizmos, from computer software to GPS systems -- and reports back to you in plain English.


advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!