7 Reasons to Forget Blu-ray

Back to blog

Thank GOD!

tsc, thank god something better than blu-ray is coming....maybe this way the price will drop and it will be the end of this non sense.

rafael @ Aug 21, 2009 23:14:04 PM

BLU-RAY WON !!!

Like Duh Obviously , LDO

Deetes of AK @ Jul 30, 2008 00:43:33 AM

You're an idiot. Blu-Ray is the future.

Dale of @ Jul 26, 2008 02:37:39 AM

blu ray???

movies....you want to see a movie? get your lazy butt off the couch

an go to the movie theatre...hd tv....you better have a high def

pocket book when it needs fixed......

don of FL @ Mar 07, 2008 23:02:03 PM

WAS THIS GUY DROPPED ON HIS HEAD?

WOW - MY PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN - I CAPTURE, EDIT AND FORMAT TO BD-J IN 1080p - AND NOT ONLY IS THE TECHNOLOGY EASY TO PLAY - I'TS EASY FOR AN INDIPENDANT FILMMAKER LIKE ME TO CAPTURE - THIS GUY HAS OBVIOUSLY NOT HAD ANY REAL EXPERIENCE WITH HD. MAYBE YOU SHOULD STICK TO WRITING IN HOUSE PRESS RELEASES FOR FOR COMPANY - COMCAST OR APPLE OR WHATEVER - THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN AND EARLY ADOPTERS LIKE ME SAW ALL THE ADVANTAGES THAT BD'S HAVE- LAIKE JAVA. I WAS PRODUCING BD'S IN 2006. MAYBE YOU SHOULD HAVE WRITTEN AN ARTICLE ON HOW BLU-RAY WORKS OR SOMETHING!

B-MAN of AL @ Mar 06, 2008 17:24:35 PM

The only benefit DirecTV and other satellite and cable providers have over BluRay now is that you can record HD programming. That's it. And this will be evaporating pretty quickly as BD drives are now available and you can now record on BD discs. Generally, you have to wait a bit longer to see some movies in HD on cable and satellite, but most new movie releases are simultaneously released in Blu Ray and regular DVD format. So I don't think any of those things will provide good competition for Blu Ray, but they will provide some alternative to people who want to get quick movie fixes without buying the movie.

Actually, the one format that can potentially still present a problem to Blu-Ray is actually regular old DVD format. It is so cheap to produce and the you can buy a DVD player for as lower as $40. However, I think this is a short run issue as Blu-Ray and BD drives becomes cheaper to produce.

BTW, if someone thinks there is no difference between 1080i on Directv and 1080P on a Blu-Ray, try looking at Cars on both formats. There is no comparison.

Chris of AZ @ Feb 29, 2008 10:39:01 AM

Apple TV

Love my Apple TV with the new update 2.0. it is attached to my LG 1080p 47 inch HD TV and could not ask for more. Thanks Apple!.

Manny of CA @ Feb 24, 2008 12:40:49 PM

HDTV won the DVD war for me

I used to run out first thing and buy the new technology until I gut stuck with not only betamax but also the quick to fail RCA Discovision. Instead of rushing for the HDDVD I was sure would win I decided to sit it out until their was a winner. In the interim I upgraded to DISH HDTV package. I discovered there are more good films available than I can watch on any given month so the battle did me a favor. I have stopped dumping a couple of hundred dollars a month on DVDs and am in no rush to purchase blue ray. As long as HDTV continues to expand I have more than enough entertainment to keep me satisfied. So in my view, neither format won. The real winner is HDTV

Philbert of CA @ Feb 22, 2008 05:15:31 AM

wow! whoever wrote this is a retard.. haha..

of PA @ Feb 22, 2008 00:37:13 AM

1080P native is the way to go

1080P does provide a noticably more detailed picture on panels as small as 42", provided they support 1080p native resolution.

So many of the cheap panels on the market today downconvert 1080i/p to a resolution that is 2.5x lower.... 720p. It's likely that David is not comparing signals on a suitable set, like the poster recent poster who came to totally the wrong conclusions about upscaling, refresh rate, and picture quality.

If you're going to compare services HD, you need to do it using a reference platform consisting of modern >42" 1080p 24fps panel, with similarly capable Blu-Ray player, and a 7.1 lossless surround setup. Once you've benchmarked one of the reference quality Blu-Ray movies, then compare the same movie from the other service providers.

Don't forget to include the entire purchasing and customer experience... movie selection, purchase, provisioning, player operation, in-movie controls, additional content.... as well as the after viewing experience... pausing / resuming view days later... watching again months later... lending to friends... taking to the cottage... displaying on a shelf.

Let's see how the services all stack up then.

Phil of AK @ Feb 21, 2008 16:44:56 PM

Back to blog

Add Your Thoughts
About You

Dave's Download

Our in-house gadget guru, Senior Writer David LaGesse, checks out the latest technologies and gizmos, from computer software to GPS systems -- and reports back to you in plain English.


advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!