Capital Commerce

Ayn Rand's Problem With the Right

By Matthew Bandyk

Posted: November 2, 2009

Ayn Rand and especially her magnum opus Atlas Shrugged are more popular than ever, as I've blogged about before. This might largely be in part to conservative activists appropriating imagery and the message from the book in their criticism of the Obama administration's economic policies. Now the literary world is getting in on the action, with a number of high-profile Rand biographies being published. The New York Times reviewed one such biography yesterday, Ayn Rand and the World She Made by Anne Heller.

If the protestors at tea party rallies carrying signs like "John Galt was right" were to read biographies of Rand, would they still tout her ideas and characters?

Here's an example: Glenn Beck has approvingly covered Ayn Rand on his show, and has likely increased her popularity among tea party activists. He has also called marriage the "building block of the universe" and criticized attempts to expand the definition of marriage to include same-sex relationships.

But, as the Heller biography reveals, Rand didn't exactly have a "traditional" view of marriage.

When Blumenthal, who changed his name to Nathaniel Branden, moved to New York, Rand followed him; she inserted herself into her protégé’s love life, urging him to marry his girlfriend; then Rand began to sleep with Branden, insisting that both their spouses be kept fully apprised of what was going on.

I don't think the Right will ever fully embrace Rand for her decidedly non-conservative views on social issues and religion. But as long as economics and the deficit are the issues of the day, she will continue to have a place in the conservative heart.

Grant

Once conservatives discover the essence of Ayn Rand's philosophy, they'll hate her just as much as the liberals do. Notice Beck's statement "Marriage is the building block of the universe." This is, essentially, Hillary Clinton's famous phrase "it takes a village" simply repackaged. Instead of the individual requiring his neighbors for validation, he requires his spouse. It's still what Ayn Rand called second-handedness (ie: defining yourself by your relations to others), just with a different target.

Ayn Rand's ideas are fundamentally opposed to both conservative and liberal thought precisely because conservative and liberal thought are fundamentally identical.

Grant of FL @ Nov 06, 2009 21:56:15 PM

It's the story.

A lot of what I hear has to do with "Atlas Shrugged" and the story that it tells. While the author is definitely part of the story I don't necessarily expect them to live by the same virtues. Just as a murder mystery writer isn't necessarily a murderer and a fantasy writer doesn't spend time with dragons. Ayn Rand's personal motivations are of little use in the discussion of the ideals being related in her story. The comparison of the looter in "Atlas Shrugged" and the idea the current administration tries to prepetuate that we are somehow owed health care, better jobs, more money, and green vehicles is a valid argument.

The idea of working hard for what you have and being proud of it is entirley American. The idea of not wanting the gov't. stepping in and arbitrarily saying you make too much money, because you make over $500,000, you need to pay more in taxes. Having gov't. say you took our money now we're cutting your pay by up to 90%. Sounds a lot like the looter or the thief.

So while Ayn Rand may not be what the right is "looking" for, the ideal of earning what you have and being thankful to those that have come before is a well learned lesson in a thought provoking story.

TheFarmer of IA @ Nov 02, 2009 22:01:31 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

Capital Commerce

Capital Commerce

U.S. News business reporter Matthew Bandyk examines the issues, people, and debates that shape the nexus of political and economic life in the nation's capital.

advertisement

advertisement

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!