On Fitness

Women: Get With the Heart Rehab Program

By Katherine Hobson

Posted: February 5, 2008

Not that you could tell it from the gender makeup at my gym in the morning, but women don't exercise as much as men. According to a 2005 Gallup poll, in fact, only 42 percent of women engage in vigorous physical activities at least once a week, compared with 56 percent of men. That's an all-around-bad trend, but the consequences are especially bad when it comes to cardiac rehabilitation, the programs for heart patients incorporating exercise, nutritional advice, counseling, and other preventive steps. There, the disparity continues: Studies have shown that women are less likely to participate in cardiac rehab, and if they do start, are as much as 30 percent more inclined to drop out. Since rehab is believed to cut the risk of further heart problems and improves quality of life, that's a gap worth tackling.

Chris Blanchard is trying to find out why women aren't sticking to rehab programs. He's a health psychologist at Dalhousie Medical School in Canada who is now leading a three-year study of 1,200 heart patients to investigate their behavior plus what their families, doctors, and hospital administratorsand specialists have to offer on possible reasons for the gender divide. One theory: Women tend to get heart disease later than men do, which means female heart patients are more likely to be older. and perhaps not as accustomed to organized or vigorous exercise as are men (or today's Mia Hamm-idolizing teenage girls). "When they grew up, exercising wasn't what a woman did," Blanchard says. "They say, 'I wasn't an exerciser then, and I won't change now.' "

Other possible reasons that he and other researchers have posited:

Gender roles. Many women are responsible for the care of kids, spouses, parents. Once they're out of the hospital, they may again shift the focus away from themselves.

The wrong sort of support. "Everyone always assumes social support is key," says Blanchard. But some women have told him that what their husbands consider support and encouragement ("Honey, why don't you hit the gym today?"), they see as nagging.

Other medical problems. Because women are older when they get heart disease, they often have additional diseases or conditions. "That means it may be harder for them to get to rehab, and they may be more frail," says Jennifer Tremmel, clinical director of Women's Heart Health at Stanford University Medical Center.

Cost and access. Women tend to outlive their husbands, and widows often have reduced financial resources. They may lack the insurance coverage or the means of transportation to make cardiac rehab possible.

I should note that men could do better, too: The American Heart Association describes cardiac rehab as "vastly underutilized," noting that only 30 percent of eligible patients participate. The medical establishment shares responsibility, says Tremmel, because it needs to more consistently make sure that referral to cardiac rehab is standard operating procedure after a heart attack or surgery. Blanchard aims to get everybody moving.

Have you noticed a gender gap among your friends and family when it comes to exercise? What do you think accounts for it?

Heart Disease and Menopause

Women are at greater risk of heart disesae once their body begins menopause. Women may begin menopause during middle age years (45-60yrs old) and are at a greater risk than men for developing heart disease due to the hormonal changes and decrease is "cardio-protective" estrogen. Women who have heart disease are not necessarily older wome who do not have the mentality of "exercise and fitness," rather - younger women are developing heart disease and many cases are being misdiagnosised. These wome are not the typical cardiac patients (ie over weight, high BP, diabetics, etc), these women are young and may have no risk factors. When heart disease is seen in a young women and she is referred (hopefully) to cardiac rehab, she may walk into a rehab setting filled with aging, overweight men. Women need cardiac rehab geared towards women. A woman's body is operates vastly different than a mans and that needs to be taken into consideration.

Cardinal Signs of a Heart Attack in a Woman:

1. Pain along the jaw line, may complain that their teeth ache.

2. Pain between the scapula (shoulder blades).

3. May not be short of breath during an attack.

4. May not break out into a sweat during an attack.

5. Tearing sensation in the chest (left side near heart).

6. Pain behind sternum.

7. Occassional pain down left arm.

Signs of a heart attack are very differnt in women.

If you are a women and have concerns - please get it checked out before it is too late. (Not everything is anxiety and fatigue)

Thanks, SP

Sonia of IL @ Mar 22, 2008 01:13:59 AM

Exercise in "old" age.

How can I get paper copies of these excellent articles - and others

to come - for many near relatives who need them? I am 95 plus 6

months and I need them. My exercises are strenuous, but not as

extensive as described here. I have a two-year-old broken left

hip and femur and a sturdy cane.

Ernest P. Bicknell II of @ Feb 08, 2008 01:13:07 AM

Response as to why women don't do Rehab - I do

I am a 68 year old female and am currently in Cardiac Rehab after suffering a serious 100% blockage. Fortunately, I have some medicare coverage and can participate. However, when my 36 visit coverage is finished, I will no longer be able to afford Rehab. On a low retirement, $300./per week is impossible. I will try to continue with a treadmill.

G Hasman of NY @ Feb 07, 2008 14:39:29 PM

Add Your Thoughts
About You

advertisement

On Fitness

On Fitness

Senior Writer Katherine Hobson writes about keeping your body fit and your diet healthy—and what those phrases actually mean, according to science. A longtime endurance athlete, she enjoys both training and Nutella in moderation. Ask her your burning exercise and nutrition questions at onfitness@usnews.com. Follow Katherine on Twitter at twitter.com/katherinehobson.

Health Check

advertisement

Blog Favorites

Subscribe

U.S. News Digital Weekly

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

U.S. News & World Report

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!