Cambridge Tops Harvard Again in World's Best Universities Rankings

See how U.S. colleges stack up against global competitors in the 2011 rankings.

October 18, 2011 RSS Feed Print

Harvard University may be America's top-ranked national university, along with Princeton University, in U.S.News & World Report's latest Best Colleges rankings, but a competitor across the pond is now stealing some of that thunder.

For the second year in a row, the United Kingdom's University of Cambridge topped Harvard in the U.S. News World's Best Universities rankings, released today and based on data from the 2011 QS World University Rankings. Developed by QS Quacquarelli Symonds, a leading global career and education network, the World's Best rankings showcase the top international universities, from North and South America to Europe and Asia and beyond. 

Six distinct indicators were evaluated to rank the top 400 universities worldwide: academic reputation, employer reputation, faculty-student ratio, proportion of international faculty, proportion of international students, and citations per faculty. The gap between Cambridge and Harvard was incredibly small—a difference of about 0.7 points in their overall scores—and can be attributed to Cambridge's more impressive faculty-student ratio.

Despite Harvard falling slightly behind a U.K. university, U.S. schools dominated the top 400 list, with six American institutions appearing in the top 10 (Harvard, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Yale University, University of Chicago, University of Pennsylvania, and Columbia University). The highest showing by a non-American or non-British university was Canada's McGill University, at No. 17. Asia's highest ranking came via University of Hong Kong (HKU), at No. 22.

[See photos of the top 10 World's Best Universities.]

A separate ranking of the top 100 Asian universities highlights the dynamism of the Asian region, where countries such as China, South Korea, and India are investing heavily in higher education to cater to both domestic and international students. This year, to better reflect the region's unique character, a distinct methodology from the top 400 global rankings was used, with indicators such as Asian academic reputation and Asian employer review.

The leaders of the pack came from Hong Kong, with Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST) and HKU taking the first and second spots, respectively. The gap between the two was very narrow—a difference of 0.2 points in their overall scores—with HKUST's research productivity giving it the edge. Japan, whose economy is slowly recovering from the devastating March 2011 earthquake and tsunami, was nonetheless dominant in the Asian rankings, with five Japanese schools in the top 10.

Meanwhile, China, the world's largest source for international students at U.S. universities, made strides with its own schools. Peking University and Tsinghua University were both among the top 20 best Asian universities, performing very well in the academic and employer reputation indicators. India didn't fare as well, due to low citations scores; its highest entries were three Indian Institutes of Technology (IIT Kanpur, Delhi, and Bombay) at No. 36, No. 37, and No. 38, respectively.

[Read about Asian M.B.A. programs on the rise.]

Like Asia, Latin America is undergoing significant development, propelled by rising economic powerhouse Brazil. The country's Universidad de São Paulo took the No. 1 spot in the top 100 Latin American universities rankings, beating Chile's Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile by 0.4 points in its overall score. The new Latin rankings use a distinct methodology, evaluating indicators such as Latin American academic reputation, Latin American employer review, and proportion of staff with Ph.D.'s.

Tags:
Latin America,
Asia,
Harvard University,
colleges,
engineering,
education,
students,
rankings

Reader Comments Read all comments (20)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

hello sir i will joy this colleage him?

nowsath 3:35AM March 27, 2012

More than 50% of the academic reputation ‘survey’ responses are from Arts and Humanities and Social Sciences and Management. This will hurt schools like Caltech very badly, the #1 school in the Times Higher Education ranking. The THE ranking criteria focus on the student experience, rather than on ‘the university disciplines’.

I would give much higher credibility to the THE ranking methodology than QS methodology. QS criteria include too many tiems that are not very important for students education quality.

QS methodology: Six indicators are drawn together to form an international ranking of universities:

40% Academic reputation (global survey)

10% Employer Reputation (Global Servey)

20% Citation per Faculty (Sciverse Scopus)

20% faculty Student Ratio

5% Proportion of International Students

5% Proportion of International Faculty

THE (Times Higher Education) Ranking Criteria

• Teaching — the learning environment (worth 30 per cent of the overall ranking score)

• Research — volume, income and reputation (worth 30 per cent)

• Citations — research influence (worth 30 per cent)

• Industry income — innovation (worth 2.5 per cent)

• International outlook — staff, students and research (worth 7.5 per cent).

You want to focus more on the quality of education the students would receive and such criteria should weigh much more heavily.

Ryan of CA 1:54PM March 06, 2012

How do you measure Employer Reputation? And which employers participate in the ranking survey? Are the employers well represented in the entire industry spectrum including Academia, Government, Entertainment industry, Technology, Drugs and Healthcare, etc., etc.?? How many hospitals participate in the survey? Which firm in Hollywood did the survey? Would the Employers favor their alma mater heavily?

If you have LOTS of international students and LOTS of international faculty, THEN did you give a high score?? Why is the International component important for my sons and daughters college education?? So, to study science, math, engineering, the international component matters a LOT?? Hey, QS, what a nonsense survey criteria and nonsense result.

Chuck of NY 1:03PM March 06, 2012

advertisement

U.S. Study Tools

Want to study in the U.S.? Get tips & tools.

U.S. News College Compass

Expanded Profiles for 1,600 U.S. Schools

Minimum TOEFL Scores

Comprehensive Financial Aid Info

Parent Question-of-the-Day

What will be your primary resource to help pay for college?
[ View Results ]