The Paper Trail

Ad in Harvard Student Paper Causes Outrage

September 9, 2009 RSS Feed Print

The Harvard Crimson finds itself at the center of controversy this week after publishing an ad in Tuesday's newspaper that questioned the existence of the Holocaust, the Crimson reports. The ad, which was submitted by the founder of the Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust, Bradley Smith, will not run the rest of the week, as was previously scheduled.

The ad asked readers to "provide, with proof, the name of one person killed in a gas chamber at Auschwitz." It prompted an overwhelming outpouring of outrage, from campus group leaders to individual undergrads. A joint letter signed by 30 undergraduates said, "Some of us are the grandchildren of Holocaust survivors and were deeply hurt by the implication that those stories passed on to us of our past—of lives lost and families destroyed—were all lies concocted by a vast Jewish conspiracy."

In a statement on the Crimson's website, Crimson President Maxwell Child blamed the advertisement's publishing on oversight and miscommunication.

“Unfortunately, with three weeks of vacation between submission and publication, that decision fell through the cracks," Child writes. “While running the ad was not our intent, we accept responsibility for our failure to carry out the planned cancellation."

Searching for a college? Get our complete rankings of America's Best Colleges.

Tags:
colleges,
Harvard University

Reader Comments Read all comments (6)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

FarmerTom is spot on. Censorship is simply that - not allowing the free exchange of information. Does not matter why. I am an adult. Let me make up my mind. The person who denies verified history or verified present events is choosing instead to create their own version of the world. Many do so in many ways. It hurts when we know the facts to be otherwise.

To Emam of XX, what is the basis of your claim of Palestine? What makes it 'yours'?

It is the fact that Moslems will not share the land and dream only of winning a war for their incapable-of-fighting-for-himself god, that prevents any real hope of peace. They demand the freedom to bomb their neighbors into the Mediterranean.

Let's try this - no more killing for God. If God wants someone dead - let Him do it. If no man raises a hand against another man for any religion, god, ceremoney, or anything else that would lead one man to interfere with or take the life of another, peace defaults.

If you think God told you to kill someone - you heard wrong! Damn it. You heard wrong.

The One Creator made all men - of all colors, shapes and sizes, whether He used Evolution or not - and He wants the killing, genocide, rape, murder, bribes, corruption, and vaccination (which violates the blood and is causing these modern diseases) to stop.

P.S. Why didn't their brothers and sisters come to the aid of the Palestinians when they needed a refuge?

Jeff Prystupa of CO 8:55PM September 21, 2009

If freedom of speech is merely the freedom to say only that which is inoffensive, then it's not really all that free. I think the Crimson errs in its decision NOT to (continue to) run the ad. If the Crimson censors the nature of the advertisements it runs, then its readers are "protected" from anything that might be deemed offensive, without being given the choice whether to be offended or not.

Please note, I am not supporting the content of the ad. I am supporting the notion that the Crimson needs to think twice about whether it really wants to be an agency of censorship. The editorial position of the paper should be made clear in its editorials. It does not want to be in the position of weighing in pro or con (presumably pro) on anything advertised in its pages...

FarmerTom of IA 12:34PM September 14, 2009

Funny how "overwhelming outpourings of outrage" come out of the woodwork whenever the Holocaust is questioned. Why? Because it's the foundation on which Israel excuses its ethnic cleansing of Palestian. Whitout the western guilt for the holocaust, the world would not turn a blind eye to what is happening. Passivity towards Palestine's oppression, rape and genocide is the west's compensation to Israel.

Eman 2:49AM September 12, 2009

The Paper Trail

Nobody knows a college better than its student newspaper. And nobody knows campus newspapers better than this blog. We sift through thousands of student newspaper headlines every day to bring you the latest, most important, or just plain weirdest news from campuses across the country. Heard bigger news or a crazier story? Send tips to papertrail@usnews.com.