The Paper Trail

NCAA Asks Schools Not to Blame Title IX

December 9, 2008 RSS Feed Print

As a number of athletic departments prepare to cut some men's teams to trim budgets, NCAA president Myles Brand has put out a call for schools to leave Title IX out of it. He has pre-emptively asked schools with shrinking athletic programs to blame the economic downturn for their problems—and not the federal law that bans sex discrimination at schools and requires institutions to maintain a commitment to women's sports, USA Today reports.

"My expectation is that over the next year or two we are going to see more" cuts of men's teams, Brand said this week in a telephone interview, "and so I am trying, frankly, to pre-empt the argument against Title IX, an unfair argument, I believe, and dissuade universities from going public with this approach."

Brand mentioned James Madison and Rutgers , schools that cut teams in 2006-07, and Delaware , where cuts have been discussed, as examples.

"I think they need to be honest about it. Any cuts at this point in sports are certainly going to be tied to financial pressures," said Brand, who urged schools not to drop any teams, men's or women's.

"I would suggest that athletics directors need to spend more smartly," he said, suggesting cutting costs in travel, facilities, and "expenditures in the highly visible sports."

Tags:
college athletics,
NCAA,
colleges

Reader Comments Read all comments (13)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

"If women can't beat men at sports, let's take their teams away" couldn't possible be an ideology of many feminists because the number of women who actually try or want to compete against men is miniscule. Why would they want to? If they did, Title IX would be focused on giving women equal access to the realm of human athletic competition, which it is not. That realm is dominated by men for many reasons. The prevalence or likelihood of a male to be more interested or involved in athletics than a female is exactly like the prevalence or likelihood of a male to be bigger or stronger than a female. It is an innate gender bias that has more to do with biology than opportunity. Since something like 75% of all collegiate males enjoy/engage in some form of athletic competition, whereas less than 20% of collegiate women do, the insanity of feminist ideology is that women-versus-women athletic programs should receive the same amount of money as men-versus-men athletic programs. Our allowing feminists to mandate this insanity via Title IX is as asinine and shamful as Brand's boneheaded and disingenuous attempt to obfuscate the true influence of this irrationality on the further cutting of men's athletic programs.

A far more equal approach to the funding of men's and women's collegiate athletic programs would be to base funding on the proportions of each gender's interest and involvement in collegiate athletics, which could be objectively measured.

Pat of CA 4:16AM March 24, 2009

This is a pretty amazing statement: the NCAA pres is actually asking schools to rewrite the truth so that the message fits his agenda. If a school is influenced by Title IX enforcement policies in the selection of men’s teams for the chopping block, it is advised not to admit it and to put all the blame on budget cuts. There is no doubt that budgets have a place to play in the decision to reduce athletics participation, but somehow men’s teams are cut in much greater numbers and percentages than women’s, despite that men are more able to put together funding plans (endowments) to take budget out of consideration (just like Princeton wrestling 15 years ago – will lessons not be learned?)

Clay McEldowney of NJ 6:44PM December 27, 2008

Essentially, the economic crisis will necessitate cutting collegiate athletics, but because of Title IX, women's teams are immune. As usual, I blame feminism. I really think their ideology goes something like this: "If woman can't beat men at sports, lets take their teams away"

anthony of NY 4:13PM December 16, 2008

The Paper Trail

Nobody knows a college better than its student newspaper. And nobody knows campus newspapers better than this blog. We sift through thousands of student newspaper headlines every day to bring you the latest, most important, or just plain weirdest news from campuses across the country. Heard bigger news or a crazier story? Send tips to papertrail@usnews.com.