The Paper Trail

Baylor Pays Freshmen to Retake SAT

October 15, 2008 RSS Feed Print

Claire Taylor/Baylor Lariat

Baylor University has been vilified by the admissions world after its student newspaper reported that the school was providing incentives for incoming freshmen to retake the SAT, the Lariat reported last week.

The school offered members of the current freshman class a $300 bookstore credit if they retook the SAT in June, after already being accepted and enrolled. Those who boosted their score at least 50 points would receive an extra $1,000 a year in their scholarship package. And if a student's new score qualified them for merit-based scholarship, he or she would be able to receive that instead of the $1,000. The school said 861 students took the test again, and 151 improved their scores by at least 50 points and received the $1,000 scholarships.

School officials defended the move, explaining that Baylor had a surplus in its merit aid budget and was trying to give its students another opportunity to earn scholarship money.

But Baylor has been lambasted, accused of abusing the SAT and trying to game college rankings like U.S. News's. One watchdog group accused Baylor of "essentially bribing students to take the SAT again." The school's Faculty Senate overwhelmingly condemned the practice, and the Lariat wrote in an editorial that it was one of the university's "cheap ploys to try to better its rankings."

Cartoon courtesy of Claire Taylor/Baylor Lariat.

Tags:
college athletics,
Baylor University,
college admissions,
football,
SAT

Reader Comments Read all comments (1)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

As Good As News carries follow-up interview with Baylor VP. See http://michaeljamesh.blogspot.com/2008/10/baylors-game-plan.html

Baylor University pays its freshmen $300 per head to retake the SATs. That's right, the same SATs they took to gain admission. John Barry, Baylor's VP of BS explained that the purpose of encouraging the already admitted students to take the SATs again was so that more would qualify for financial aid. As Good As News arranged a follow-up interview with Mr. Barry:

AGAN - Mr. Barry, couldn't you just give out more financial aid by lowering the qualifying scores without paying freshmen to retake the SATs?

VPBS - No Comment.

AGAN - Is there any real reason for Baylor to do this - other than gaming the ranking system at US News & World Report by reporting scores from SATs taken by Baylor freshmen (who test in a relaxed atmosphere knowing they are already admitted), when other colleges are ranked based on scores from SATs taken by high school juniors and seniors competing under tremendous pressure?

VPBS - Well as I said, everybody at Baylor is very pleased with the higher scores.

AGAN - Why not have your grad students retake SATs and report them to US News, wouldn't they score higher than the freshmen?

VPBS - Thank you, we'll look into that.

AGAN - Baylor has over 3,000 freshmen but only 861 retook the SATs, despite the $300 reward. Does this mean A) the average Baylor student is wealthy, B) the average Baylor freshman paid someone to take their SATs for them in high school and can't risk exposure now or C) all of the above?

VPBS - Can I go to the bathroom now?

AGAN - Is Baylor still affiliated with the Baptist Church?

VPBS - Very much so, and Baptists all over the country are very pleased with the higher scores.

AGAN - Where does Baylor stand on Texas secession?

VPBS - The University hasn't taken any official position, but unofficially the administration is solidly pro Lone Star Republic. For us, it would be the good old days, we were chartered by the Republic of Texas and we'd love to go back. The way we see it, life would be a lot easier if we were just competing with Aggies, Horn Frogs and Mustangs. OK, let's face it. Off the record, (spoiler alert - do not read on if you feel constrained by any journalistic scruples - obviously not an issue for As Good As News, we report, you decide) the SAT thing is a gimmick to make us look better. But we are desperate. Have you ever seen Baylor, ever been to Waco? Pretty bleak, right? A lot of people around here think those Branch Davidians weren't so much crazy as just really desperate to leave. The closest thing we've got to excitement is W's ranch, and that was down to four visitors last year. Now add in the tiny little problem that Baylor is dry. That's right. We're trying to recruit students to attend a school in Waco, a school in Waco that bans alcohol. A school with a football team that went 0-8 in conference last year. Now if you think we'

michael h of NJ 12:50PM October 16, 2008

The Paper Trail

Nobody knows a college better than its student newspaper. And nobody knows campus newspapers better than this blog. We sift through thousands of student newspaper headlines every day to bring you the latest, most important, or just plain weirdest news from campuses across the country. Heard bigger news or a crazier story? Send tips to papertrail@usnews.com.