On Education

Rhee Challenges Obama to Get Behind Her on School Reform

December 2, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (20)

Earlier this year, U.S. News interviewed Michelle Rhee, the controversial chancellor of public schools in Washington, and had this to say about her:

"If you want to quickly become the most unpopular person in a city, close down a school. No, make that 23 schools. Then, fire 34 principals, offer buyouts to 700 teachers (while pressuring hundreds more to leave), and fire 98 employees from the school district's central office. That's what Michelle Rhee . . . has done since she took control of the district in the summer of 2007. Of course, she's not trying to make friends; she's trying to turn around one of the nation's most troubled school districts." (Read full story.)

If there was any doubt about her priorities, consider what Rhee says in an interview with Time this month. According to the magazine, Rhee, a Democrat, almost voted for Sen. John McCain for president, but a close friend ultimately persuaded her to cast her vote for Barack Obama, the president-elect. "It was a very hard decision," she explains. "I'm somewhat terrified of what the Democrats are going to do on education."

Rhee may not be interested in making new friends, but she certainly needs the president-elect and Democratic lawmakers on her side. After all, Congress and the president approve the capital city's budget. So, why is Rhee opening up so publicly about her reservations of an Obama administration now that the election is over? Here's a guess: To signal to Obama that if he really intends to improve education, starting with D.C.'s troubled school system, his choice for education secretary cannot be someone who will undermine the work of school reformers like her.

Rhee's comments come as speculation ramps up that the job of education secretary might go to Linda Darling-Hammond, a Stanford University professor whom Obama recently appointed as head of his education policy transition team. (Read about other potential picks.) Darling-Hammond also advised Obama during the campaign. Education reformers like Rhee, however, don't think Darling-Hammond is right for the job. They worry that she has taken sides with the unions by resisting ideas that include merit pay for teachers and eliminating tenure.

Teacher unions have been a major stumbling block for Rhee, who is seeking to win support for proposals that would make it easier for her to fire incompetent teachers and give bonuses to the best ones. She has introduced two compensation plans, one that strips teachers of tenure but allows them to earn up to $130,000 if they meet performance goals based on student test scores, and the other that lets teachers keep tenure but gives them a modest raise. So far, the unions have chosen not to hold a vote on either proposal, leaving Rhee frustrated.

Obama certainly doesn't need Rhee's blessing to appoint whomever he considers best for the job, but through her public commentary, Rhee has put him on notice that she has no intention of backing down from her proposals and that she would like to have him on her side. She hinted as much when she told Time, "It would send a huge message if this administration actually took a side on where we are with the union negotiations here." Soon, Rhee might get her answer.

Tags:
Michelle Rhee,
education reform,
Obama administration,
education

Reader Comments Read all comments (20)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

york action biological area difficult shop stance

correygunt of AZ 2:12PM January 17, 2010

Linking teacher bonuses to student test scores and other incentive-pay provisions under Pl 107-110 ? Now Rhee's executive direction is place the teachers on a 90 day plan and principles resign. Misguided ship is headed for an iceberg ! Tac ! NCLB is a punitive law that uses flawed standardized tests to label schools as failures and punish them with counter productive sanctions. Punitive tests and label approach to accountability is ineffective for school improvement.Equality for democracy !Motivate to engage and see Guskey and Marzano ! Get the pep bands and sail for school spirit! Learning is fun and so are school buildings ! Have a parade and dress up like story book characters and stop the streets ! See the mayor for a permit and work that process! Take an academic concept and design a float for the parade.This teach to a bubble test has taken the fun and creativity out of teaching higer level thinking and problem solving.Take a concept and turn it into an innovative big idea but wait,it's not on the test.See Voices Across America question #1 !"End the mandates on NCLB." Hillary Clinton !

Peace of NC 6:07AM December 13, 2008

Finland,Sweden and Denmark soar in academics ! We want our Universial Pre-K to focus on personal responsibility,project based learning and inner-net access. They don't test until High School and participate in the PISA and scored at the top of TIMSS. The US places 19th out of 40 countries in reading.20th in science and 28th in math. Changing the means for measuring school progress? How about we push for Public Accountablity and transparancy for standardized tests.There is very little over sight for these corporations and it's a goldmine industry under NCLB. We have states under NCLB that are using tests less expensive to score from using such assessments. Connecticut sued the federal government over it and it's narrowed the curriculum.Push out high stakes testing and no ding from state policy please.Check out the videos with Hammond,Dr.Wood and Noguera on The Forum for Educational and Democracy.We realize there is an old family connection between McGraw-Hill and President Bush but let's shoot for fair balance of interests with oversight.The US can't be ranked 19th and we're going for #1! Team up !Keep your eye on those educational tax credits and philanthropy tax credits ! Stay balanced in the saddle on those vouchers too! What's the funding formula under NCLB,a law unfunded and let's go ! We have a D in the US and placed 19th out of all the countries ! Get the ball down the court and score !

KIm of NC 5:02AM December 13, 2008

On Education

Report cards may come out only twice a year, but education news happens every day. Here is where U.S. News writers grade the latest developments, from school districts banning the game of tag to congressional debates that affect college affordability. Check regularly for the most recent updates.

advertisement