Who Won the Second Debate Between Mitt Romney and Barack Obama?
President Barack Obama and GOP nominee Mitt Romney faced off Tuesday night at Hofstra University in Hempstead, N.Y., for the second presidential debate. Obama was coming off a disappointing performance in the first debate in Denver two weeks ago, which had spurred a notable gain for Mitt Romney in both national and swing state polls. Romney, meanwhile, had to prove that his winning Denver performance was not a fluke, and that he could ride his newfound momentum to Election Day.
The second debate was town-hall style engagement with moderator Candy Crowley of CNN directing the candidates to questions asked by undecided voters. Obama and Romney revisited topics from the first presidential debate—and last week's vice presidential debate—including job growth, the deficit, and the diplomatic murders in Libya. However, the candidates also covered new ground with questions on immigration and female pay inequity.
With Obama coming at Romney far more aggressively than he did in Denver, the debate had several heated exchanges, with the candidates often interrupting and talking over one another,
Who won the second presidential debate? Here is the Debate Club's take:
The Arguments
Obama — The town hall style of the debate gave Obama the edge, but Romney's strength on substance keeps him in the race
FORD O'CONNELL,
Republican Strategist, Conservative Activist, and Political Analyst
Comment
(
Obama — Mitt Romney lost by underestimating Barack Obama
JAMAL SIMMONS,
Principal at The Raben Group
Comment
(
Obama — Romney doesn't have the experience necessary to be the leader of the free world
BRAD BANNON,
President of Bannon Communications Research
Comment
(
Romney — Mitt Romney won by listing President Barack Obama's failures
JUDSON PHILLIPS,
Founder of Tea Party Nation
Comment
(
Obama — The debate was a tie, but Romney needed to present a clearer policy picture
JAMIE CHANDLER,
Political Scientist at Hunter College
Comment
(
Romney — Independents lean Romney, but will be turned off by the partisan tone of the Hofstra debate
LARA BROWN,
Assistant Professor of Political Science at Villanova University
Comment
(
