Should Welfare Recipients Be Tested for Drugs? >
Welfare Programs Should Promote Self-sufficiency
We ought to provide aid on the basis of reciprocal obligation
December 15, 2011
About Robert Rector:
Robert Rector, senior research fellow in domestic policy at the Heritage Foundation, is a leading authority on the welfare system. His recent papers include "Understanding Poverty in the United States."
The U.S. government this year spent over $900 billion on 70 different means-tested welfare programs. These programs (not including Social Security, Medicare, or Unemployment Insurance) provide cash, food, housing, medical care, and targeted social services to poor and low-income Americans.
[GOP: Drug Tests for Unemployment Applicants.]
But welfare assistance should not be a one-way handout or open-ended entitlement. We ought to provide such aid on the basis of reciprocal obligation. Taxpayers should provide support to those in need; recipients, in return, should engage in responsible and constructive behavior as a condition of receiving aid.
Requiring welfare recipients to stop using illegal drugs is a core element of reciprocal obligation. And it's a real issue. Most related studies indicate that one third of welfare recipients use illegal drugs.
As welfare spending approaches $1 trillion a year, taxpayers have a right to insist that their financial help not only goes to those who truly need it but that it's not wasted on frivolous or self-destructive activities such as drug use. Evidence shows that drug testing has the potential to significantly reduce unnecessary welfare spending and misuse of funds.
Florida's policy of requiring drug testing for welfare applicants, for example, appears to have reduced new welfare enrollments by as much as 48 percent. Potential applicants who use illegal drugs simply chose not to enter the welfare system. Of course, they could sign up for welfare in the future, but first would have to refrain from taking the illegal drugs. The choice was theirs.
[GOP: Dems Reneged on Budget Deal.]
Finally, welfare programs should be designed to promote self-sufficiency among able-bodied adults and to discourage long-term dependence on government. Scientific evaluation of Florida's drug-testing requirement showed that welfare recipients who used illegal drugs had earnings that were 30 percent lower than those who did not. Quite simply, drug use was linked to lower levels of work.
Any serious effort to promote employment and self-sufficiency should include steps to decrease illegal drug use among those on welfare. It's just common sense that a well-designed program of drug testing is one of the important tools in any effective welfare-to-work strategy.
- Mort Zuckerman: Why America Should Worry About the Euro Crisis.
- Should Democrats Abandon the Tax on Millionaires?
- U.S. News & World Report Debate Club: Should Congress Extend Federal Unemployment Benefits?
- Other Arguments
-
#2729201
Yes — Why pay someone not to work when he has voluntarily taken himself out of the hiring pool?
JACK KINGSTON, U.S. Representative, Georgia's 1st District
-
#3623177
Yes — We are overdue to renew welfare reform efforts and make additional gains
DAVID VITTER, U.S. Senator, Louisiana
-
#4458257
Yes — Require drug testing only of welfare applicants with a history of substance abuse
LAWRENCE M. MEAD, Professor of Politics and Public Policy at New York University and Visiting Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute
-
#5414689
No — Drug testing welfare recipients is an intrusion into private lives not consistent with U.S. values
PETER CAPPELLI, George W. Taylor Professor of Management at the Wharton School and Director of Wharton's Center for Human Resources
-
#6241611
No — Welfare recipients are no more likely to have drug problems than anyone else
MATTHEW BODIE, Professor and Associate Dean for Research and Faculty Development at Saint Louis University School of Law
-
#7281654
No — The assumption that people on public assistance use drugs at a higher rate than the general population is erroneous
VANITA GUPTA, Deputy Legal Director of the American Civil Liberties Union
-
#8235620
No — Suggesting welfare recipients are worthy of suspicion unfairly singles the group out for disdain
JOY MOSES, Senior Policy Analyst with the Poverty and Prosperity Program at the Center for American Progress
-
#9251664
No — Drug testing perpetuates myths and scapegoats the unemployed
CHRISTINE L. OWENS, Executive Director of the National Employment Law Project
