Debate Club

Should the U.S. Discourage Israel From Attacking Iran?

Nuclear experts believe Iran is coming close to producing a nuclear weapon of its own. Iran claims to only be implementing nuclear programs for energy and medical purposes, but recent intelligence suggests otherwise. Israel has expressed the most concern about the prospect of a nuclear armed Iran, as Iran’s president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad does not recognize Israel as a sovereign state and has vowed that Israel “will disappear.” Monday, Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu met President Obama at the White House to discuss the Iranian situation and other issues in the Middle East. Analysts believe that Israel is considering a preemptive strike on Iran’s suspected nuclear weapons facilities. Some, including many of the GOP candidates for president, have criticized Obama for not being tough enough in support of Israel against Iran. But Obama has pushed back against that characterization: “The United States will always have Israel’s back,” Obama said in a speech Sunday to American Israel Public Affairs Committee and again Monday before his meeting with Netanyahu. However others worry that if Israel attacks Iran, it will drag the United States into war as well.  Here is the Debate Club’s take on whether the United States should discourage Israel from attacking Iran:

The Arguments

#2
15 Pts

No — Israel cannot avoid action against Iran indefinitely

ILAN BERMAN, Vice President of the American Foreign Policy Council Comment

#3
6 Pts

No — Despite sanctions, Iran shows no signs of slowing its nuclear program

JAMIE M. FLY, Former Director for Counterproliferation Strategy at the National Security Council Comment (2)

#4
-1 Pts

Yes — There is time for diplomacy and sanctions to work on Iran

BRIAN KATULIS, Senior Fellow at Center for American Progress Comment (2)

#7
-18 Pts

Yes — Let's hope Israel has the good sense to refrain from hitting Iran's nuclear program

DANIEL J. GALLINGTON, Senior Policy and Program Adviser at the George C. Marshall Institute Comment (8)

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
Organizations Masquerading as Tax-Exempt is the Real IRS Scandal

The real scandal at the IRS is electioneering groups getting tax-exempt status.

E.W. Jackson Proves the Tea Party Learned Nothing

By nominating E.W. Jackson, Virginia Republicans hope extremism will save them.

IRS, AP and Benghazi Are Not Obama Scandals

The word "scandal" doesn't appropriately describe anything going on in Washington these days.

Democrats Should Be Worried About Polls After Obama Scandals

Democrats should be more worried about President Obama's approval ratings.

Tea Party IRS Rally Should Wait Until After Moore Tornado Recovery

Tea party rallies against the IRS should wait until the tornado victims are taken care of.

God Bless America and the Boy Scouts

The Fund does the right thing by pushing the Boy Scouts to lift its ban on gay members.

IRS, AP and Benghazi Show the Failure of Obama's Big Government

Giving an inefficient organization like the IRS more responsibility makes it more likely to screw up, not better able to solve this nation’s problems.

Coburn Wants Oklahoma Tornado Aid Offset With Budget Cuts

Oklahoma Senator Tom Coburn wants spending cuts before aid is sent to tornado victims in his own state.

Advertisement