Debate Club

Should the United States Build a Fence on Its Southern Border? >

Border Fence Part of Larger Solution

A border fence is an integral part of a larger solution

October 25, 2011

About Colin Hanna:

Colin Hanna is president of Let Freedom Ring, a conservative public policy non-profit organization.

A border fence is a necessary element in any serious effort to achieve border security, but it is not the only element. At least three elements are required: infrastructure, manpower and technology. Each one makes the other two more efficient. If any one is omitted, the other two must be increased to an impractical extent.

Take manpower, for example: without some physical barrier, attempting to secure the entire 1,951 mile US-Mexican border would require over 100,000 Border Patrol agents, a financial and administrative impossibility. Even if good technology is employed – cameras, drones and the like – securing the border with manpower and technology alone is still a practical impossibility. Likewise, infrastructure alone won't do the job. Infrastructure may be interpreted to mean a fence, wall or barrier that would impede both individuals and vehicles. At some point, every fence or wall can be scaled or breached. Infrastructure plus manpower could achieve border security, but not as effectively as infrastructure, manpower and technology.

[Read: The Conservative Case Against a Border Fence.]

Our website, www.WeNeedAFence.com shows a design that incorporates all three elements. It has two parallel barriers that would be somewhat time-consuming and cumbersome to breach or scale. Detection devices– cameras, motion detectors, etc. – would be mounted near the fence to notify the nearest Border Patrol station that an attempted intrusion was underway. Between the elements there would be a patrol road that would permit the speedy deployment of manpower to the point of intrusion. None of these elements is particularly complex or expensive, but when coordinated as three essential elements in a system, they can achieve real border security. We also recommend monitored gates at several points to facilitate the legal passage of persons, vehicles and goods.

Other Arguments
#1

No — Physical fences will only buy time in dealing with illegal immigrants

RALPH BASHAM, Former Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection

#2

Yes — A fence needs to be used in combination with other tools

MARK KRIKORIAN, Author of 'The New Case Against Immigration, Both Legal and Illegal' and 'How Obama is Transforming America Through Immigration'

#4
#5

No — The Obama administration has failed miserably at securing the border

ALFONSO AGUILAR, Former Chief of the U.S. Office of Citizenship.

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
President Obama's Code Pink Heckler Medea Benjamin Was Plain Rude

It's become acceptable for people to interrupt the president while he is delivering a formal speech on a deadly serious topic.

Obama Commerce Nominee Penny Pritzker’s Tax Problem

Obama’s Commerce Department nominee has some Romney-esque tax issues.

Oklahoma Tornado Reminds Us of the Value of Teachers

The Oklahoma tornado reminds us of all the roles teachers take on.

IRS, AP and James Rosen Scandals Strike at the First Amendment

The Obama scandals paint a picture of an administration at odds with the First Amendment.

Anthony Weiner Is Too Liberal to Be New York City Mayor

New York City doesn't need another Democratic mayor.

Organizations Masquerading as Tax-Exempt is the Real IRS Scandal

The real scandal at the IRS is electioneering groups getting tax-exempt status.

E.W. Jackson Proves the Tea Party Learned Nothing

By nominating E.W. Jackson, Virginia Republicans hope extremism will save them.

IRS, AP and Benghazi Are Not Obama Scandals

The word "scandal" doesn't appropriately describe anything going on in Washington these days.

Advertisement