Debate Club

Should the Supreme Court Overturn Proposition 8? >

Proposition 8 Is Bad Law and Must Be Overturned

In legal terms, Prop 8 denies equal protection to millions of families

March 4, 2013

About Casey Pick:

Casey Pick is a policy fellow with the National LGBT Bar Association, and a licensed attorney in the state of California.

As Americans weigh in on the question of whether the Supreme Court should overturn Proposition 8, arguments range from political to personal, from high academia to "common sense." As a member of the National LGBT Bar Association, my take on this question is legal. What does fidelity to our highest law, the United States Constitution, require?

There is no rational basis upon which to deprive committed same-sex couples of the legal rights, responsibilities, and recognition conferred by civil marriage. As legal professionals and advocates for justice—and citizens subject to this legal regime—members of the LGBT Bar witness this inequity every day.

[See a collection of political cartoons on gay marriage.]

While not every injustice is illegal, our Constitution is clear: No state may "deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." In legal terms, Proposition 8 denies equal protection to millions of families who are "similarly situated" to their straight neighbors; they live, love, and die like everyone else. As officers of the court, we are tired of treating them differently.

We have guided countless same-sex couples through a labyrinth of unjust taxation on their property, healthcare, and shared income. We have advised parents on the necessity of adopting their own children, so that even when the law does not recognize couples as spouses the state will acknowledge them as guardians. We have been present when, after decades together, a dying partner desperately looks for a loophole to allow his husband to keep their home—precious time that should be spent with loved ones, not lawyers.

[Read the U.S. News Debate: Should Gay Marriage be Legal Nationwide?]

The injustice of Proposition 8 is documented in wills, trusts, contracts and powers of attorney, the piles of paperwork that our community builds to try to replace the marriage licenses denied by the state—and as much as we try, these expensive and complicated measures fail far more often than they succeed.

We have been contending with Proposition 8 and laws like it for years, waiting for the day that the United States Supreme Court would take up the case. Our experiences have made it clear—Proposition 8 is bad law, and must be erased.

Tags:
marriage,
California,
Proposition 8,
Supreme Court,
LGBT rights,
civil rights
Other Arguments
#1
#2

Yes — The Supreme Court must strike down marriage discrimination

EVAN WOLFSON, Founder and President of Freedom to Marry

#3

Yes — Prop 8 supporters can't explain how marriage equality harms heterosexual marriages

ADAM UMHOEFER, Executive Director at the American Foundation for Equal Rights.

#5

Yes — There's no compelling reason to deny same-sex couples the right to marry

STACEY LONG, Director of Public Policy and Government Affairs at the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force

#6

Yes — Prop 8 subverts the heart of the Fourteenth Amendment

ILYA SHAPIRO, Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute

#7

No — Allowing interracial marriage has no bearing on the argument for same sex marriage

JOHN C. EASTMAN, Chairman of the Board of the National Organization for Marriage

#8

No — Prop 8 isn't discriminatory—it merely reflects reality

CHRIS GACEK, Senior Fellow at the Family Research Council

Reader Comments ()

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
President Obama's Code Pink Heckler Medea Benjamin Was Plain Rude

It's become acceptable for people to interrupt the president while he is delivering a formal speech on a deadly serious topic.

Obama Commerce Nominee Penny Pritzker’s Tax Problem

Obama’s Commerce Department nominee has some Romney-esque tax issues.

Oklahoma Tornado Reminds Us of the Value of Teachers

The Oklahoma tornado reminds us of all the roles teachers take on.

IRS, AP and James Rosen Scandals Strike at the First Amendment

The Obama scandals paint a picture of an administration at odds with the First Amendment.

Anthony Weiner Is Too Liberal to Be New York City Mayor

New York City doesn't need another Democratic mayor.

Organizations Masquerading as Tax-Exempt is the Real IRS Scandal

The real scandal at the IRS is electioneering groups getting tax-exempt status.

E.W. Jackson Proves the Tea Party Learned Nothing

By nominating E.W. Jackson, Virginia Republicans hope extremism will save them.

IRS, AP and Benghazi Are Not Obama Scandals

The word "scandal" doesn't appropriately describe anything going on in Washington these days.

Advertisement