Debate Club

Should the Medicare Eligibility Age Be Raised? >

We Should Encourage Americans to Keep Working, Not Retire

Raise the age of eligibility of Medicare and tie it to life span

December 6, 2012

About Robert Moffit:

Robert Moffit is a senior fellow at the Heritage Foundation.

Let's start with a basic fact. We are not living in the 1930s. Therefore, the policies crafted to suit the conditions of the '30s are not responsive to the very different conditions that prevail today.

When President Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Congress enacted Social Security in 1935, the average life span was 62. Still, even the liberal Roosevelt administration set the normal retirement age above that level: age 65. When Congress and the liberal Johnson administration created Medicare in 1965, they still kept the normal retirement age of 65, even though the average life span had increased to 70.2 years.

[See a collection of political cartoons on Congress.]

Congress has since raised the normal retirement age for Social Security to 67. But Congress made no such change for Medicare, even though conditions changed. By 2009, the average life span was 78.2 years, and it is expected to reach almost 81 years in 2030.

During fruitless discussions with congressional leaders on raising the debt ceiling last year, President Barack Obama briefly joined a growing consensus of independent analysts who support gradually raising Medicare's age of eligibility to 67, tracking the Social Security change—by two months every year. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that such a change would yield a 10-year savings of $124 billion. Gradually raising the Medicare eligibility age to 68, as recommended by my colleagues at the Heritage Foundation, would yield a 10-year savings of $244 billion.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the budget and deficit.]

Ideally, Congress should gradually raise the normal age of eligibility for Medicare and Social Security to 68 and then tie it to average life span. Instead of encouraging Americans to retire, we should encourage them to keep working. For many older Americans, it will be an opportunity to live a healthier and happier life.

Rather than encourage some of our most resourceful and talented workers to go out to pasture, we should tap their talents and rich experience and increase America's productivity. Congress could help this along by providing tax relief for those who want to work beyond normal retirement age. With a Medicare reform based on a defined contribution to employer-based and other plans, Congress could also encourage older persons to keep their current health plans or purchase even better coverage.

 

Corrected on 12/06/2012: A previous version of this article misstated the year Social Security was enacted. It was enacted in 1935.

Tags:
healthcare,
Medicare,
deficit and national debt,
fiscal cliff
Other Arguments
#1

No — Pushing up the eligibility age will hike prices across the healthcare system

DEBRA WHITMAN, AARP Executive Vice President for Policy and International

#2
#3
#4
#5

Yes — Retirement programs must be adjusted to reflect changing demographics

JAMES CAPRETTA, Visiting Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute

Reader Comments ()

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
IRS, AP and Benghazi Show the Failure of Obama's Big Government

Giving an inefficient organization like the IRS more responsibility makes it more likely to screw up, not better able to solve this nation’s problems.

Coburn Wants Oklahoma Tornado Aid Offset With Budget Cuts

Oklahoma Senator Tom Coburn wants spending cuts before aid is sent to tornado victims in his own state.

Crowdfunding Zack Braff's Film And Robert Griffin's Gifts Is a Mistake

Rich people don't need donations from the public.

Poll Shows Americans Find Obama's IRS Story Barely Believable

There is still something fishy about the scandal at the IRS.

Do Benghazi, AP and IRS Scandals Reflect Obama’s Leadership Style?

It may be that a flawed leadership style is filtering down to the rest of the government.

In Marine Umbrella Incident, Republicans Still Deny Obama Is President

Umbrellagate is more proof that Obama's critics cannot acknowledge that he is, indeed, president.

Obama Isn't Nixon, but Needs More Friends in Washington

President Barack Obama needs to make more friends in Washington.

Republicans Can't Forget the Economy During Obama Scandals

Scandals provide good fodder for the GOP, but it can't forget about fixing unemployment.

Advertisement