Debate Club

Should States Be Able to Collect Sales Tax on Goods Sold Online? >

Online Sales Tax Would Create an 'Unlevel' Playing Field

Online sales tax could open a Pandora's box of overzealous collection efforts

August 8, 2012

About Andrew Moylan:

Andrew Moylan is vice president of government affairs for the National Taxpayers Union.

States should only be allowed to tax businesses within their borders and businesses should only have to answer to tax authorities in states where they're physically located. This time-tested principle ought to be uncontroversial on its face, yet federal legislation like the Marketplace Fairness Act would turn it on its head by enabling states to compel compliance with their tax laws on out-of-state sellers.

Current law prevents a government from forcing a retailer to collect sales tax unless it has a tangible physical presence in the state. Far from being some accidental "loophole," this fundamental safeguard protects taxpayers from overzealous collection efforts and is reflected in virtually every facet of modern tax policy. Dispensing with that constitutional standard could threaten to open a Pandora's box. After all, this sort of foolish course helped bring about the collapse of the Articles of Confederation as states aggressively extended their tax authority beyond their borders to the detriment of interstate commerce.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the economy.]

Despite supporters' claims, the Marketplace Fairness Act would create a distinctly "unlevel" tax playing field. When you shop in a brick and mortar store, the owner isn't forced to interrogate you about your residence, consult your hometown's myriad rules and regulations to determine the correct rate, and then send the tax proceeds to a distant bureaucracy. You're simply charged the one rate in effect for where the store resides, regardless of your eventual destination. Yet the Marketplace Fairness Act would require online retailers to jump through ridiculous tax collection hoops for more than 9,600 different jurisdictions, denying them the method used for traditional in-store sales. Why can't E-tailers be allowed to use the same system?

[Read the U.S. News debate: Is a Flat Tax a Good Idea?]

But hasn't technology made it easy to accurately process sales taxes across the nation? Not at all. The Senate Commerce Committee held a hearing on this issue last week where it was revealed that a cheerleader for the Marketplace Fairness Act was improperly (and probably illegally) charging the wrong sales tax rate to "remote" customers, despite bragging that its tax calculation software was a snap.

Online sellers who manage to gain a toehold in the marketplace haven't done so because they're not collecting sales taxes (especially considering they have the added cost of shipping to customers). They're succeeding because of the convenience and selection that appeal to some shoppers. Governments shouldn't tear down taxpayer protections just to appease some old-school retail competitors, who can still deploy advantages of their own.

Tags:
sales tax,
internet,
shopping,
business
Other Arguments
#1
#2

No — A nationally-mandated Internet tax is anything but fair

JIM DEMINT, Republican Senator from South Carolina

#3

No — There are better ways to tax Internet companies while encouraging interstate economic competition

ADAM THIERER, Senior Research Fellow for the Mercatus Center at George Mason University

#5

No — Internet sales tax can do a great deal more economic harm than good.

NEIL NIMAN, Associate Professor of Economics at the University of New Hampshire

#6
#7

No — States already collect most online sales tax

STEVE DELBIANCO, Executive Director of NetChoice

#8

Yes — Internet businesses should live by the same rules as "mom and pop" stores on Main Street

MICHAEL MAZEROV, Senior Fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

#9

Yes — Online-only retailers are exempt from collecting sales tax at every point of purchase

MICHAEL KERCHEVAL, President of the International Council of Shopping Centers

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
Obamacare Opponents Have to Keep Pushing Repeal

The way to repeal Obamacare is to hasten its ugly results.

Can Obama's Berlin Speech Match John F. Kennedy's and Ronald Reagan's?

The two famous Berlin speeches almost never were.

Reform Conservatives Need to Tackle Unemployment and Jobs

"Reform conservatives" are doing good work, but need to think about the ills of long-term unemployment.

If Background Checks are Good Enough for Guns, They're Good Enough for Jobs

Employers need to be able to consider all factors before making a hire.

NSA Leaker Edward Snowden Is Neither a Whistle-Blower Nor a Civil Disobeyer

Resisters who break a law must accept that they may be arrested and have a duty to submit to punishment.

Obama Should Bring Small Business Owners on His Trip to Africa

This country needs a national reality show.

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s Divorce and Robert Kraft’s Super Bowl Ring

What took Lyudmila Putina so long?

Syria, Israel and the Obama Administration's Absentee Foreign Policy

Creating a mess you are going to leave for someone else to clean up is not a good way to manage U.S. foreign policy.

Advertisement