Debate Club

Should Newt Gingrich Drop Out? >

By Staying in the Race, Gingrich Helps Romney

Best case scenario is that Gingrich might be able to play kingmaker at a deadlocked convention

March 14, 2012

About Matthew Dickinson:

Dr. Matt Dickinson is a professor at Middlebury College. He is the author of Bitter Harvest: FDR, Presidential Power, and the Growth of the Presidential Branch and co-editor of Guardian of the Presidency: The Legacy of Richard E. Neustadt. His current book project, titled The President and the White House Staff: People, Positions and Processes, 1945-2008, examines the growth of presidential staff in the post-World War II era.

There are four possible reasons why Newt Gingrich might justify staying in the race. Only one is remotely plausible. The first is the slight chance that he could win a plurality of the delegates heading into the convention. But with only a few remaining southern states to be contested, and with Rick Santorum demonstrating that he can compete with Gingrich in this region, Gingrich has virtually no chance of taking the delegate lead. So far he has demonstrated very little strength outside of the South, and there's no reason to believe that support will be forthcoming in other regions.

[See a collection of political cartoons on Newt Gingrich.]

The second reason is to prevent a Romney victory. But by staying in the race and splitting the Tea Party, evangelical, and conservative vote with Rick Santorum, Gingrich actually increases the likelihood that neither he nor Santorum can amass the delegates needed to stop Romney's march to the nomination. Under the new Republican Party delegate allocation rules, it is very difficult to gain big chunks of delegates, and to prevent one's opponent from doing the same, without winning over 50 percent of the vote in a state. Gingrich's presence makes that scenario less likely.

The third reason is to amass delegates and hope to emerge victorious from a brokered convention. Even here, however, Gingrich will have to devise a rationale for why he should be chosen over his two rivals, both of whom will likely enter the convention with more delegates and a stronger claim to be the nominee.

[Opinion: The Weakest Presidential Field in History?]

The fourth and most plausible reason is to play kingmaker at a deadlocked convention. Assuming no candidate wins the nomination on the first ballot, it is possible that Gingrich can use his delegate haul as currency in an effort to buy support for his favored candidate—or for a position in the next Republican nomination. Even this strategy poses risks, however. By staying in the race and splitting the vote and delegates with Santorum, Gingrich may actually increase the likelihood that Romney clinches the nomination outright—thus preventing him from playing kingmaker at all.

The bottom line is that there is only one reason for Gingrich to stay in the race—and it may not be reason enough.

Tags:
2012 presidential election,
Newt Gingrich
Other Arguments
#1
#2

Yes — Rick Santorum has earned the right for this to be a two-man race

FORD O'CONNELL, Republican Strategist, Conservative Activist, and Political Analyst

#4

Yes — The best way for Gingrich to get revenge on Romney may be to step aside

RON BONJEAN, Former Chief of Staff for the Senate Republican Conference

#5

No — Gingrich's only shot is to force a floor fight in Tampa

DAVID CROCKETT, Author of 'Running Against the Grain: How Opposition Candidates Win Presidential Elections'

#6

No — Newt Gingrich has no self-interested reason to drop out just yet

LARA BROWN, Author of 'Jockeying for the American Presidency: The Political Opportunism of Aspirants'

#7

No — If Rick Santorum loses to Mitt Romney, it's his own fault, not Newt Gingrich's

KRYSTAL BALL, MSNBC Contributor and Former Democratic Nominee for Congress in the First District of Virginia

#8
About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
President Obama's Code Pink Heckler Medea Benjamin Was Plain Rude

It's become acceptable for people to interrupt the president while he is delivering a formal speech on a deadly serious topic.

Obama Commerce Nominee Penny Pritzker’s Tax Problem

Obama’s Commerce Department nominee has some Romney-esque tax issues.

Oklahoma Tornado Reminds Us of the Value of Teachers

The Oklahoma tornado reminds us of all the roles teachers take on.

IRS, AP and James Rosen Scandals Strike at the First Amendment

The Obama scandals paint a picture of an administration at odds with the First Amendment.

Anthony Weiner Is Too Liberal to Be New York City Mayor

New York City doesn't need another Democratic mayor.

Organizations Masquerading as Tax-Exempt is the Real IRS Scandal

The real scandal at the IRS is electioneering groups getting tax-exempt status.

E.W. Jackson Proves the Tea Party Learned Nothing

By nominating E.W. Jackson, Virginia Republicans hope extremism will save them.

IRS, AP and Benghazi Are Not Obama Scandals

The word "scandal" doesn't appropriately describe anything going on in Washington these days.

Advertisement