Debate Club

There Are Smarter Ways to Deal With Marijuana Than Legalization


Because marijuana legalization would expose us to unknown risk—and because there are better options than both "let 'em use" or "lock 'em up"—I join both major presidential candidates and the American Medical Association in opposing marijuana legalization. It is a reckless policy option. But that does not mean we have to be content with the status quo either. There are smarter ways to deal with marijuana than either extreme.

According to the nonpartisan RAND Corporation, legalization would greatly reduce the price of marijuana, thereby significantly increasing use, especially among kids. This is a problem because the brain is developing until age 25, and recently completed research shows that pot can significantly decrease IQ, double the risk of a car crash (according to the most exhaustive review ever undertaken on the matter), and significantly increase the chance of contracting a mental illness. Today's marijuana is not the same stuff parents think back today with nostalgia about—in fact it is about 4-5 times stronger in potency.

[Read the U.S. News Debate: Should Welfare Recipients Be Tested for Drugs?]

Even the supposed benefits of legalization may not pan out. Ironically, under legalization, we could see arrest rates for marijuana actually increase, similar to what we see with alcohol (there are 2.7 million arrests a year for alcohol versus 800,000 for marijuana), as more users drive high or violate marijuana growing and using laws. Furthermore, there is no guarantee that the underground market would significantly diminish. In a legal market, where marijuana is taxed, the well-established illegal drug trade has every incentive to remain. Today's thriving underground market for tobacco is a good example of this. The drug trade is so profitable that even undercutting the taxed price would leave cartels with a handsome profit. Marijuana legalization would also do nothing to loosen the cartels' grip on other illegal trades such human trafficking, kidnapping, extortion, piracy, and other illicit drugs (marijuana accounts for a minority of revenues gained by drug trafficking groups). Producing marijuana en masse at home is also much easier to do than with tobacco or alcohol. We can expect a thriving grey market.

But these facts do not mean we need to go overboard in our approach. Low-level marijuana users should not be imprisoned for their use, and former users with an arrest record should not be prevented from getting a job or accessing social benefits. In fact, isolating those with an arrest record can be counterproductive, increasing their interaction with the illicit economy. We need to have a sane conversation about marijuana arrests among disadvantaged communities, too, to ensure equal justice under the law.

[See a collection of political cartoons on healthcare.]

The good news is that we have more choices than merely enforcement or legalization. We can get smarter about our marijuana policy without throwing the next generation under the bus. Before they become the guinea pigs for a risky policy experiment, voters in Washington, Colorado, and Oregon would do well to remember that.

Kevin Sabet

About Kevin Sabet Former Senior Policy Advisor to President Obama's Drug Czar


Other Arguments

1,232 Pts
Marijuana Use Should Not Be a Crime

Yes – Marijuana Use Should Not Be a Crime

Alison Holcomb Drug Policy Director of the American Civil Liberties Union

1,119 Pts
Marijuana Regulation Works and Prohibition Fails

Yes – Marijuana Regulation Works and Prohibition Fails

Paul Armentano Deputy Director of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws

572 Pts
Stop Wasting Time Pretending Marijuana Prohibition Works

Yes – Stop Wasting Time Pretending Marijuana Prohibition Works

Morgan Fox Communications Manager at the Marijuana Policy Project

-958 Pts
Marijuana Legalization's Costs Outweigh Its Benefits

No – Marijuana Legalization's Costs Outweigh Its Benefits

David G. Evans Special Adviser to the Drug Free America Foundation

You Might Also Like

See More