Debate Club

Should federal authorities be able to close medical marijuana dispensaries in California? >

Medical Marijuana Is California's Business

State has right to experiment; federal government has more important things to do

October 26, 2011

About Morgan Fox:

Morgan Fox is the communications manager at the Marijuana Policy Project, a non-profit organization dedicated to reforming marijuana laws on a state and federal level.

Our system of government was designed to allow the states to act as laboratories of democracy, experimenting with policies that might be most appropriate for them. One of the roles of the federal government is to protect that right, but according to current federal law, that right does not extend to marijuana policy. In 2009, however, the Obama administration signaled that it would restore that right, in part, and not interfere with states that allowed the use of marijuana for medical purposes. While only Congress can change federal drug laws to truly free the hands of the states to enact compassionate marijuana policies, the president promised that he would not waste Justice Department resources going after patients and providers who were in compliance with state law. He should keep that promise.

[See a collection of political cartoons on the economy.]

The recent federal announcement of intent to crack down on dispensaries in California is misguided, both practically and ideologically. To begin with, closing dispensaries will do nothing to impact the illicit distribution of marijuana. If anything, the patients directly affected by the closures will be forced to obtain their medicine from criminals, thus enriching the very people the Department of Justice is hoping to put out of business.

Many patients are unable to grow their own medical marijuana or duplicate the variety and quality available in collectives and dispensaries. By targeting dispensaries, the federal government is ensuring that their quality of life will suffer, in addition to their personal safety.

Medical marijuana has become an important part of California's economy as well. Last year, these legitimate businesses reported more than a billion dollars in revenue and contributed more than $150 million in taxes to the local, state, and federal governments. At a time when national and state budgets are in dire straits, and Americans are hurting for jobs, it makes no sense to punish businesses for being successful.

Not only does this crackdown affect the medical marijuana industry but the media as well. The Department of Justice, as part of the crackdown, has said that it will prosecute newspapers and TV and radio stations that run ads for medical marijuana. Without the revenue from these businesses, many media outlets will have to cut staff or close down entirely. Can California afford to lose jobs and revenue to justify a misguided, and ultimately fruitless, strategy?

The vast majority of Californians support medical marijuana. They should be allowed to continue to experiment with regulations that will govern the industry required to provide patients with safe access to their medicine. The federal government has more important things to worry about.

Tags:
marijuana,
California,
employment,
economy,
Department of Justice
Other Arguments
#1
#2

No — Shutting down dispensaries sends patients into the illicit market

KRIS HERMES, Media Spokesperson for Americans for Safe Access

#4
#5

Yes — The FDA, not popular opinion, tests and approves medicines

KEVIN SABET, Former Senior Adviser for Policy to White House Office of National Drug Control Policy Director

#6

Yes — System makes criminals money, makes highways unsafe, and doesn't make the sick any better

PETER BENSINGER, Former Administrator of the United States Drug Enforcement Administration

#7

Yes — Marijuana dispensaries have increased incidents of drug use and crime

JOHN REDMAN, Executive Director of Californians for Drug Free Youth

Reader Comments Read all comments (10)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Why not? I think it is ridiculous something that has already been passed as a state law still sparks such contriversy. It has been around in California since 1996, it has lifted up the economy in ways. Hasn't proved to do much if any damage. Let the people who actually need this for medicinal use to smoke it. It's the people with law degrees saying no to this. Think what is somebody before they go into any government position? A few doctors, and majority lawyers or people with a law degree. They make money off of marijuana and other drug cases. That is why it strikes such a big argument. They will never pass anything they are making money off of. The people need something to do to actually clear this up. Its all dumb in my opinion.

Alec of MD 10:22AM May 10, 2012

It is counter productive to criminalize a substance which is so widely used in society. The U.S. has the highest rate of incarcerations per capita of any developed country, and many prisoners are there because of relatively minor drug offenses.

The prohibition of alcohol in the 1920s simply created a huge underground network of criminals who exploited the law by providing what people were seeking. There are horrible criminals today who commit heinous crimes, in protection of their 'turf' and profits associated with the illegal marijuana trade.

I agree, let people cultivate their own if they wish, perhaps restricting it to five plants per household. True, enforcement of such a law would be difficult but could be used when growing operations were obviously large. Medical marijuana facilities should be monitored for compliance to regulation, much as restaurants cannot have unclean and unsanitary conditions.

Tim B of ID 2:22AM October 28, 2011

Jesus said to do unto others as we would have them to do unto us. None of us would want our child thrown in jail with the sexual predators over marijuana. None of us would want to see an older family member’s home confiscated and sold by the police for growing a couple of marijuana plants for their aches and pains. It’s time to stop putting our own family members in jail over marijuana.

If ordinary Americans could grow a little marijuana in their own back yards, it would be about as valuable as home-grown tomatoes. Let's put the criminals out of business and get them out of our neighborhoods. Let's let ordinary Americans grow a little marijuana in their own back yards.

Here's one way that IT IS REALLY WORKING: Arresting the criminals and collecting a fee from registered growers (and bringing in thousands of dollars to support the county budget); what a great plan! This is the way to build a better America! http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/2011/07/the-pot-republic-one-sheriffs-quietly-radical-experiment.html

The current proposal before Congress, bill HR 2306, will allow states to decide how they will regulate marijuana. You can email your Congressperson and Senators at http://www.usa.gov/Contact/Elected.shtml to discuss HR 2306.

And a big THANK YOU to the courageous, freedom loving legislators, governors, and countless others who are working so hard to bring this through! You’re doing a great patriotic service for all of America!

ConservativeChristian of GA 10:53AM October 27, 2011

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.


Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.


You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
Obama's Remarkable Silence on Latin American Press Abuses

President Obama's silence on press freedom in Latin America is troubling.

Why the Media Is Giving Romney a Pass on Trump's Birtherism

Why the media hasn't pressed Mitt Romney about Donald Trump's birther fantasies.

Romney's Bain Experience Wasn't Real American Capitalism

The fact that Bain Capital served to make money for investors, not to create jobs, could endanger Romney.

Why Is Mitt Romney Embracing Birther Donald Trump?

Maybe Trump is Romney's idea of a rich guy that common people can relate to?

Does Barack Obama Actually Want to Be Re-Elected?

The president's lack of enthusiasm jeopardizes his campaign.

3 Reasons Why the Scott Walker Wisconsin Recall Election Matters

Scott Walker is a canary in a coal mine.

The Right's Fixation With 'Vetting' Obama

American voters can use the past four years to judge Obama's qualifications as president

Voters Tuning Out Flood of 2012 Super PAC, Campaign Ads

This will be the year of grassroots voters, not Nielsen families.

Advertisement