Debate Club

Unemployment Insurance Is Financial Life Support for Millions

By + More

Now is not the time to reduce Unemployment Insurance:

  • Only 58.2 percent of the working-age population is employed, down from 63.3 percent just four years ago.
  • 14 million workers are seeking employment.
  • Basic UI provides only 26 weeks of assistance. Currently 43 percent of the unemployed have been without work for more than 27 weeks.
  • The combination of slow job growth and the large number of people seeking employment has caused many workers to stop looking for work, thereby seriously jeopardizing future economic growth.

The economy faces the dual challenge of maintaining people's connection to the labor force while creating enough jobs to employ them.

[Unemployment Drops--Does Obama Deserve the Credit?]

Currently, only 56 percent of the officially unemployed receive any assistance and for half of them, their UI runs out before they find new jobs. The average benefit across the nation is $296 per week, below the poverty threshold and hardly enough to dissuade workers from seeking employment. Seven states provide up to an additional 67 weeks of UI and 27 states provide up to an additional 73 weeks of UI.

UI is definitely no replacement for a job, but it is a financial life-support system for millions of American workers. We clearly must do everything we can to create more jobs, but now is not the time to reduce UI.

Howard Rosen

About Howard Rosen Resident Visiting Fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics

Tags
economy
employment
insurance
unemployment

Other Arguments

#2
72 Pts
Putting People Back to Work Must Be the Ultimate Goal

Yes – Putting People Back to Work Must Be the Ultimate Goal

Geoff Davis U.S. Representative, Kentucky's 4th District

#3
65 Pts
Unemployment Insurance Will Promote Economic Recovery

Yes – Unemployment Insurance Will Promote Economic Recovery

Sander Levin U.S. Representative, Michigan’s 12th District

#4
34 Pts
Withdrawing Unemployment Insurance Will Not Solve Job Crisis

Yes – Withdrawing Unemployment Insurance Will Not Solve Job Crisis

Carl E. Van Horn Professor of Public Policy and Director of the John J. Heldrich Center for Workforce Development at the Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy at Rutgers University

#5
15 Pts
Americans Don't Turn Their Backs on Americans in Need

Yes – Americans Don't Turn Their Backs on Americans in Need

Lloyd Doggett U.S. Representative, Texas’ 25th District

#6
7 Pts
No Free Lunch in Subsidy Programs

No – No Free Lunch in Subsidy Programs

Chris Edwards Economist at the Cato Institute

#7
-6 Pts
More Unemployment Insurance Won't Stimulate Growth

No – More Unemployment Insurance Won't Stimulate Growth

James Sherk Senior Policy Analyst in Labor Economics at the Heritage Foundation

You Might Also Like


See More