Debate Club

China Does More to Damage to the American Economy Than Any Other Nation

By + More

Yes, China is certainly America's number one adversary.

China refuses to play by the rules of the global economy while simultaneously growing its military capabilities, gobbling up strategic resources, stifling dissent at home, green-lighting cyber intrusions abroad and showing increased signs of nationalism.

China is not a sworn enemy of the United States, nor do I hope it ever becomes one. But no nation-state has done more damage to American interests in recent times.

[Read the U.S. News debate: Should Congress Interfere with China's Currency Policies?]

It's not unusual for a nation to act in its own economic interest. But what sets China apart is its blatant disregard for the established rules of global trade. China manipulates its currency, heavily subsidizes its industries, blocks market access, permits the theft of intellectual property, promotes forced technology transfers and degrades its own environment, all to gain a competitive advantage.

The consequences have been severe in China and abroad. While many observers hoped that China's accession to the global trading system more than a decade ago would lead to more openness, reciprocity with the West and a respect for the rule of law, that hasn't happened.

Instead, millions of Chinese citizens die prematurely due to heavy pollution. Millions of American manufacturing workers have lost their jobs over the past 12 years. China passed the United States over the past few years to lead the world in manufacturing and exports. And, the U.S. trade deficit with China reached $315 billion last year, a record unsurpassed in the history of such statistics.

[See a collection of political cartoons on Chinese hacking.]

What does Beijing do with this wealth? It builds up its military, develops satellite-killing missiles and funds what is widely acknowledged as the world's most intrusive cyberhacking operation — one that threatens American businesses and homeland security interests.

Things could grow much worse if China became openly belligerent, which is why our relationship with Beijing must be carefully managed. China may not be a superpower in the technical sense, but it is far from benign. So long as Beijing poses as an adversary in the quest for democratic rights, open markets, respect for the rule of law and economic stability, we must remain vigilant.

Scott Paul

About Scott Paul President of the Alliance for American Manufacturing

foreign policy

Other Arguments

12 Pts
A New Approach Is Needed to Counter China's Power

No – A New Approach Is Needed to Counter China's Power

Evan Moore Senior Policy Analyst at the Foreign Policy Initiative

5 Pts
China Is Becoming More Like the U.S.

No – China Is Becoming More Like the U.S.

Teemu Ruskola Professor of law at Emory University

2 Pts
There's No Simple Way to Describe U.S.-China Relations

No – There's No Simple Way to Describe U.S.-China Relations

Ely Ratner Deputy Director of the Asia-Pacific Security Program at the Center for a New American Security

You Might Also Like

See More