The Bishops Are in No Place to Cry Foul

By SHARE

The Obama administration's decision to require employers—including religiously affiliated institutions that employ people of all beliefs—to provide insurance coverage for contraception was correct; neither the administration nor Congress should alter this stance—not if they care about fairness, women's health, or discrimination. According to the nonpartisan Guttmacher Institute, 98 percent of American women use contraception at some point in their lives, including Roman Catholic women. Clearly, contraception is a key component of basic healthcare for women of all faiths.

[Rick Newman: Obama's Common-Sense Deficit.]

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, the lobbying arm of the Catholic church, does not speak for the Catholics in the pews. Polls show that the majority of Americans, including Catholics, support the Obama administration's stance. For the bishops to claim a right to use their religious beliefs to discriminate against millions of women is against American values.

Let's be very clear. This is a public healthcare issue. This is not a religious liberty issue. No one is requiring any faith to stop preaching that contraception is sinful, if that's what its followers believe. No one is forcing anyone to buy contraception. And the church itself is exempt, as is any religious entity like a temple or mosque that exists primarily for the purpose of advancing the faith and serves and hires primarily people of the faith.

[New Culture War Will Help Rick Santorum, Barack Obama.]

However, religiously affiliated institutions like hospitals and universities that serve and employ people of all beliefs must play by the same rules as any other employer that operates in the public. Catholic hospitals alone employ almost 800,000 people. No one would seriously suggest that these people, along with teachers, custodians, and administrative staff at religiously affiliated universities and other organizations, have signed up to join the church simply because they've taken a job.

This is not a new idea. Twenty-eight states already require employers, including faith-based institutions, to provide contraception coverage, to no perceivable harm to religious liberty. Courts in New York and California have already ruled that such requirements do not violate religious liberty. The bishops are in no place to cry foul.

[Majority of Catholics Believe Employers Should Cover Birth Control.]

Religious freedom means allowing everyone to make their own decisions, including the deeply personal decision of whether and when to start a family. It does not give religious groups the right to make these decisions harder by imposing their beliefs on others by denying access to vital services.

Louise Melling

About Louise Melling Deputy Legal Director for the American Civil Liberties Union

Tags
Obama administration
Obama, Barack
religion
birth control

Other Arguments

#1
42 Pts
Religious Exemptions Must Be Employed Judiciously

Yes – Religious Exemptions Must Be Employed Judiciously

Jessica Arons Director of the Women's Health and Rights Program at Center for American Progress

#2
42 Pts
Contraception Mandate Doesn't Protect Religious Liberty

No – Contraception Mandate Doesn't Protect Religious Liberty

Hannah Smith Senior Counsel at the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty

#3
28 Pts
Contraception Mandate a Profound Violation of Religious Freedom

No – Contraception Mandate a Profound Violation of Religious Freedom

Jeanne Monahan Director of the Center for Human Dignity at the Family Research Council

#4
16 Pts
Secularists Are Fanatics Too

No – Secularists Are Fanatics Too

Andrea S. Lafferty President of Traditional Values Coalition

#6
6 Pts
We Cannot Trust the President's Promises

No – We Cannot Trust the President's Promises

Janice Shaw Crouse Senior Fellow of Concerned Women for America's Beverly LaHaye Institute

#7
5 Pts
The Edict of the HHS Death Panel Cannot Stand

No – The Edict of the HHS Death Panel Cannot Stand

Patrick Vaughn General Counsel at American Family Association

#8
4 Pts
Government Cannot Dictate Private Beliefs

Yes – Government Cannot Dictate Private Beliefs

Roger N. Lancaster Director of Cultural Studies at George Mason University

#9
-3 Pts
Like Komen, Politicians Attack Birth Control at Their Own Risk
#11
-13 Pts
Blame the Church, Not the State

Yes – Blame the Church, Not the State

Joan Hoff Research Professor of History at Montana State University

You Might Also Like


See More