Religious Exemptions Must Be Employed Judiciously

By SHARE

Yes, Catholic hospitals and other religious institutions should be required to cover birth control for their employees. Millions of women are employed by or attend school at religious institutions in this country, and to exempt these institutions would leave these women without coverage for a basic preventive health service that can cost $600 a year.

[New Culture War Will Help Rick Santorum, Barack Obama.]

Family planning results in better health outcomes for women and their children—a woman who has a planned pregnancy is more likely to be in better health when she gets pregnant and more likely to seek prenatal care, and children who are born at least two years apart are healthier. Family planning is also the most effective tool we have in reducing unintended pregnancy and the need for abortion.

Houses of worship are exempt under the Health and Human Services rule guaranteeing no-cost contraceptive coverage. But nonprofits, like hospitals, that serve the general public, employ people of all beliefs, and engage in secular, commercial activities must offer the same health benefits to their employees that any other business must provide. No right is absolute and this is a fair balancing of the competing interests at play.

[Rick Newman: Obama's Common-Sense Deficit.]

Freedom of conscience is a bedrock American principle and religious exemptions can be a useful way to protect conscience, but they must be employed judiciously. Otherwise, issues of conscience become trivialized and turn into excuses for discrimination. If religious employers are allowed to object to contraceptive coverage now, will they one day be able to opt out of covering HIV services, HPV tests, blood transfusions, or end-of-life care? If we are not careful, claims of religious liberty could be exploited by religious organizations to justify noncompliance with laws they prefer to ignore.

The small minority in this country that opposes contraception is entitled to its opinion and is free to preach it as often as it wants. But this very dispute belies the fact that only a fraction of followers practices what is being preached. Only 2 percent of sexually active Catholic women have not used some form of modern birth control. Contraception opponents must not be allowed to resort to economic coercion where persuasion has failed.

[Obamacare Birth Control Mandate Tramples Religious Liberty.]

The HHS rule rightly honors the conscience of women and gives them the freedom to decide whether using contraception is morally correct.

Jessica Arons

About Jessica Arons Director of the Women's Health and Rights Program at Center for American Progress

Tags
birth control
Obama administration
religion
Obama, Barack

Other Arguments

#2
42 Pts
Contraception Mandate Doesn't Protect Religious Liberty

No – Contraception Mandate Doesn't Protect Religious Liberty

Hannah Smith Senior Counsel at the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty

#3
28 Pts
Contraception Mandate a Profound Violation of Religious Freedom

No – Contraception Mandate a Profound Violation of Religious Freedom

Jeanne Monahan Director of the Center for Human Dignity at the Family Research Council

#4
16 Pts
Secularists Are Fanatics Too

No – Secularists Are Fanatics Too

Andrea S. Lafferty President of Traditional Values Coalition

#6
6 Pts
We Cannot Trust the President's Promises

No – We Cannot Trust the President's Promises

Janice Shaw Crouse Senior Fellow of Concerned Women for America's Beverly LaHaye Institute

#7
5 Pts
The Edict of the HHS Death Panel Cannot Stand

No – The Edict of the HHS Death Panel Cannot Stand

Patrick Vaughn General Counsel at American Family Association

#8
4 Pts
Government Cannot Dictate Private Beliefs

Yes – Government Cannot Dictate Private Beliefs

Roger N. Lancaster Director of Cultural Studies at George Mason University

#9
-3 Pts
Like Komen, Politicians Attack Birth Control at Their Own Risk
#10
-6 Pts
The Bishops Are in No Place to Cry Foul

Yes – The Bishops Are in No Place to Cry Foul

Louise Melling Deputy Legal Director for the American Civil Liberties Union

#11
-13 Pts
Blame the Church, Not the State

Yes – Blame the Church, Not the State

Joan Hoff Research Professor of History at Montana State University

You Might Also Like


See More