Debate Club

Alberto Gonzales: The Government Must Use All Available Technology to Protect Americans

By SHARE

The revelation that our government obtained a court order for customer records of Verizon has reignited a debate in our country over security and liberty in a time of war or danger. This tension is as old as the Republic.

Our enemies have demonstrated their willingness to use any advantage or tool to hurt us. I believe our government should use all available technology to protect us, so long as there are sufficient checks and balances to discourage abuse. Government searches are lawful if they are reasonable. In this instance, information was sought pursuant to a statute passed by Congress and obtained under the constraints of a court order. Key members of Congress were briefed regarding these activities.

[Check out our editorial cartoons on President Obama.]

Our courts have already held that there is no reasonable expectation of privacy under the Constitution in our records in the possession of third parties such as Verizon. Although there may be no constitutional implications here, we should nevertheless remain vigilant, and insist on oversight of these activities so they are not abused.

Having served in the White House during the September 11th attacks, however, I support this program and the efforts under the law by our government to keep us safe.

Alberto R. Gonzales

About Alberto R. Gonzales Former United States Attorney General

Tags
NSA
privacy

Other Arguments

#1
76 Pts
The Founding Fathers Rejected a System of Authoritarian Power

Yes – The Founding Fathers Rejected a System of Authoritarian Power

Jonathan Turley Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University

#2
70 Pts
Obama Administration Continues Bush's Unconstitutional Policies

Yes – Obama Administration Continues Bush's Unconstitutional Policies

Shayana Kadidal Senior Managing Attorney at the Center for Constitutional Rights

#4
-51 Pts
John Yoo: Government Data Collection Doesn't Violate the Constitution

No – John Yoo: Government Data Collection Doesn't Violate the Constitution

John Yoo Former Deputy Assistant Attorney General in the Office of the Legal Counsel of the U.S. Department of Justice

You Might Also Like


See More