Debate Club

Is the Senate's Immigration Deal a Good Plan? >

Senate Plan Has Essential Outline for Immigration Reform

Senate plan has the substance and the momentum to lead to worthy immigration reform

January 29, 2013

About Tamar Jacoby:

Tamar Jacoby, a fellow at the New America Foundation, is president of ImmigrationWorks USA, a national federation of small business owners working for better immigration law.

The framework for immigration reform released this week in the Senate is the Washington equivalent of a starter pistol kicking off a foot race. This is the beginning of what is sure to be a long, intense, suspenseful negotiation about how to fix the U.S. immigration system.

The good news: the eight senators, Democrat and Republican, who drafted the framework have gotten the debate off to an excellent start.

The framework is encouraging for two reasons.

First and foremost: substance.

There are many things wrong with America's broken immigration system: outmoded, poorly designed policies and lack of policies that create problems for many different groups of immigrants and Americans alike. Any immigration reform worthy of the name will be a complex package—an engine with many moving parts. And what's promising about the Senate outline is that it addresses, at least in passing, most of the problems that need fixing: visa programs for high-skilled workers and low-skilled workers, immigrants already in the United States and those who might come in the future, enforcement on the border, enforcement in the workplace, U.S. employers, U.S. workers, immigrant families and more.

[See a collection of political cartoons on immigration.]

In other words, the baby has 10 fingers and 10 toes—all of the essential parts. Nothing could be more important at the outset. That's the threshold test for any blueprint.

What has to happen now: Lawmakers have to put flesh on the bones of the outline. And as with any negotiation, the devil will be in the details.

But this is the framework's second strength: the momentum it creates for lawmakers gearing up to grapple with the thorny issues.

For most of the past six years, immigration has been a third-rail issue in Washington. As recently as six months ago, Democrats and Republicans were squabbling over it on the campaign trail. The idea that there might be a bipartisan deal in the works would have seemed laughable in October.

But here we are: It's only January. Many members of Congress are only just settling into their offices. Yet this ambitious group of Democrats and Republicans has already sketched out a bipartisan compromise—and if anything, they're competing with the president to get out ahead on the issue and move it forward.

Why are we all so surprised? Isn't this how Congress is supposed to work? Just when we were starting to think lawmakers had all forgotten how.

 

 

Tags:
Congress,
immigration reform

Reader Comments ()

About Debate Club

A meeting of the sharpest minds on the day's most important topics, Debate Club brings in the best arguments and lets readers decide which is the most persuasive. Read the arguments, then vote. And be sure to check back often to see who has gotten the most support—and also to see what's being discussed now in the Debate Club.

Have ideas about what the Club should be debating? E-mail it to dclub@usnews.com.

You can also join the debate on Facebook or follow Debate Club on Twitter.

Advertisement
Cartoons
Thomas Jefferson Street Blog
IRS, AP and Benghazi Show the Failure of Obama's Big Government

Giving an inefficient organization like the IRS more responsibility makes it more likely to screw up, not better able to solve this nation’s problems.

Coburn Wants Oklahoma Tornado Aid Offset With Budget Cuts

Oklahoma Senator Tom Coburn wants spending cuts before aid is sent to tornado victims in his own state.

Crowdfunding Zack Braff's Film And Robert Griffin's Gifts Is a Mistake

Rich people don't need donations from the public.

Poll Shows Americans Find Obama's IRS Story Barely Believable

There is still something fishy about the scandal at the IRS.

Do Benghazi, AP and IRS Scandals Reflect Obama’s Leadership Style?

It may be that a flawed leadership style is filtering down to the rest of the government.

In Marine Umbrella Incident, Republicans Still Deny Obama Is President

Umbrellagate is more proof that Obama's critics cannot acknowledge that he is, indeed, president.

Obama Isn't Nixon, but Needs More Friends in Washington

President Barack Obama needs to make more friends in Washington.

Republicans Can't Forget the Economy During Obama Scandals

Scandals provide good fodder for the GOP, but it can't forget about fixing unemployment.

Advertisement